Reflections on society, politics and nature – vol. 72

This is one in a series of posts with brief notes on society, politics, and nature. I sometimes include short personal notes as well. Click “read more” to see the entries in this installment.

IRAN WAR

The US and Israel has started an illegal war against Iran. It’s illegal according to international law, and also US law. It cannot in any way be justified as self-defense.

As usual, they get away with it because of the US position in the world, and Israel still riding a wave of sympathy from the horrors of WW2 – in spite of years and decades of genocidal actions from their side.

Most commentators leave out that the Iranian regime came about through another US intervention, aimed at toppling the Iranian democratic government. The reason was that this democratic government wanted to nationalize the oil industry, to the benefit of the Iranian people.

These kinds of interventions have inherently unpredictable consequences. Iran got a strongly authoritarian anti-Western government following the US intervention decades ago. And who knows what this current war may lead to. It can go in a large number of very different directions. The wast majority of these are not good for the people in Iran, neighboring countries, or the world.

History shows that these kinds of interventions and wars rarely go to plan. It risks destabilizing the country and the region for years and decades. There is also a risk that any future governments may be worse than the previous/current one.

In this case, Iran has prepared for this war for decades. They have plans in place to replace killed leaders, and it will likely be someone more extreme. They have warned about making the war regional. Iran is a notoriously difficult country to invade, purely based on geography. (It’s huge and mountainous.)

Also, air wars don’t lead to regime change. (Other than making the regimes more extreme.) Any ground war will easily become yet another quagmire. And these kinds of interventions only create more hatred towards the aggressor, in this case the US and Israel.

Of the many possibilities for how this unfolds, let’s look at two extremes.

One is that it’s a brief war. Trump pulls out relatively quickly and declares victory. Most goes back to how it was, apart from increased repression and entrenchment from the Iranian regime. Trump seems to receive his orders from Israel in this situation, and a brief war that maintains status quo is not in Israel’s interest. Still, Trump may eventually – within weeks or a few months – decide to declare victory and leave devastation in his wake.

The other is a long war. If the US and Israel want regime change, it has to be a land war. And it has to, eventually, involve US and Israeli troops on the ground. This can last for a very long time, considering the geography of Iran. It will involve neighboring countries. And it will be accompanied by Iranian terrorism around the world. There is no guarantee that even this will lead to a regime change, or that a future regime will be any more democratic or friendly towards Israel and the West. There is also the possibility of an eventual civil war within Iran.

Trump in his hubris likely assumes the situation is simple and will go according to plan. (If he has one, which it doesn’t look like he has apart from a vague idea of “success”.) And just about everyone else in the world knows it very likely won’t. We know that life is far more complex, and people have their own minds. (In this case, Iran has prepared for decades for this war, the opposition is weak and disorganized, air strikes alone will not lead to regime change, and Iran has the means to drag it out indefinitely.)

Although Trump didn’t start any big wars during his first period, his rhetoric and orientation changed dramatically before the second period, so what we are seeing now is no surprise.

The name of this war, “Epic Fury”, sounds like it was created by someone with the emotional maturity of a five year old, and little to no empathy or understanding of the seriousness and tragedy or war.

Of course, these kinds of unnecessary and optional wars is what empires do. In this case, it’s a way for Trump to distract from poor ratings, terrible predictions for Republicans for the midterm elections this fall, and the Epstein files. In his deluded mind, the war may also appear as an easy win.

To me, right now, this looks like Putin’s invasion of Ukraine. Putin thought it would be easy, just like Trump likely sees this war as easy. In each case, it will be anything but.

Also, in both cases, informed ordinary people – at least in Norway and Europe in general – seem to have a more accurate picture of the situation than the leaders. Putin’s invasion of Ukraine was seen as meaningless and unnecessary, and an inevitable quagmire for Russia no matter how the war itself went. (The Ukrainians would never stop fighting an occupation, and they would eventually win even if it would take decades.) Trump’s invasion of Iran is seen as an equally meaningless and unnecessary war. If he persists, it will very likely be another quagmire.

To some extent, some leaders may want a quagmire since it gives a lasting external enemy and distraction, but it leads to nowhere good in the long run. In some cases, it leads to the end of the attacking empire. Quagmire wars drains huge amounts of resources, leads to internal unrest and dissatisfaction, makes them lose sympathy and support internationally, and is often both an expression of declining empires and contributing cause of their disintegration.

All of this is an expression of a strong domination orientation and culture. The unnecessary wars. The assumptions that it will go according to plan and be easy. The want to dominate. The assumption you have the right to decide the internal affairs of other countries. The desire for control.

From a legal point of view, the war is unjustified and illegal. From a practical point of view, it’s profoundly misguided. From a distraction point of view, it works.

P.S. When it comes to Israel, initiating this war seems like a trauma response, just like their ongoing genocide. They choose strategies that increase regional hatred against them, make them lose international sympathy, and ultimately make them less safe.

UPDATES / ADDITIONS

MARCH 2026

The US/Israel killed the previous head of state in Iran, and he is now – some days later – replaced by his son. He is likely to be more extreme than his father, not the least because most of his close family was killed in the attack. He has nothing to lose. That he would be replaced by someone as or more extreme was predicted and close to inevitable.

Iran is using relatively inexpensive drones to attack US bases and US allies in the region. This drains the US anti-missile/anti-drone rocket supply, and is an excellent tactic to eventually bring the US into a situation where they have to pull out. (Or escalate, which would create a long and terrible war.)

A few more days in, and Iran has now made the Hormuz strait unsafe for tankers. This was also predicted and close to inevitable. It means higher oil prices in the world and a huge boost for the Russian economy. As usual, Trump seems to intentionally and sometimes unintentionally (?) act in ways that benefit Putin. He also clearly doesn’t care about the finances and well being of ordinary people, including the citizens of the US.

The media is largely ignoring the main issue of this war – that it’s clearly illegal according to international law. If I was an editor or journalist, that’s something I would put at the forefront of most or all reporting on this war.

Who benefits from this war? Putin, obviously, since it drains US resources and improves Russian economy. Also, it benefits China. They may be a ruthless authoritarian regime, but they are at least smart about it. They focus on what matters, not unneccesary wars. So they will continue to strengthen, while the US weakens itself and continues to erode its empire.

Over two weeks in, and we are in a current energy crisis that was avoidable. Most countries in the world have chosen – and it is a choice – to continue to rely on fossil fuels. That makes them and their energy situation very vulnerable. If we collectively had transitioned to renewable energy, we would not have an energy crisis now.

It’s now three weeks since the war started. It seems increasingly likely that this will be a long war with a ground invasion, which means likely disaster for just about everyone involved and for the global economy. Trump is in the predicted and forecasted escalation trap.

Mainstream Western media, including CNN and BBC, now seem to blame Iran for fighting back. Who started this war? Are they not allowed to defend themselves?

Someone commented that authoritarians don’t understand that people have agency. They surround themselves with people who fear speaking up to them, and assume the rest of the world is like that too. Putin thought Ukrainians would welcome the Russian invasion and occupation. Trump thought the Iranian government would fold. Just about everyone else knows that the world is not that simple and people have their own mind and motivations.

I AM BAFFLED, AND NOT

As so often, I am partly baffled by this. History shows that these kinds of operations rarely if ever go to plan. An air war won’t give regime change. The opposition in Iran is weak and disorganized and will not be able to create a regime change. A ground war will be an immensely costly and drawn out quagmire. (Because of the mountainous geography and huge distances, the huge number of US/Israeli soldiers required to fight and win over a million Iranian soldiers, and a regime fighting a religious war and for their survival.)

So why does anyone think this is a good idea? Why do 40 percent of the population in the US still support it? Are they complete idiots? The answer is likely and sadly “yes”, in the sense that they are uninformed and easily misled.

APRIL 2026 – ILLEGAL, MISGUIDED, COSTLY

It’s now the first week of April, one month after the initial attacks by the US and Israel on Iran. I see that European media overwhelmingly (?) and accurately depict this war as illegal, misguided, and profoundly costly for the Iranian people, West Asia, and the world. And the mainstream US media, for whatever reason and in their usual lack of integrity, tend to lean more towards the Trump view.

I also notice that the US media seem to focus on the handful of US citizens killed so far, and much less on the thousands of Iranian killed. That is an expression of the dehumanization of empire, and I am surprised that editors and reporters go along with it. Are they in service of empire, or humanity? I guess the answer is, as it usually is, empire.

In terms of the Hormuz strait, Trump seems to want NATO countries to clean up his mess. Having someone clean up his mess is what he is used to, and he again brings his personal life to the world stage.

Also, I see Trump and others in the US advocate for a ground invasion of Kharg island, which also seems profoundly misguided. It can easily become a death trap, and it won’t impact Iran that much. (See, for instance, this video from CBC.)

PURGING OF THE US MILITARY

The Trump administration are firing competent top military leaders to replace them with less competent loyalists, and are gradually weeding out black and female leaders. This is obviously a recipe for disaster. Replacing people with less competent yes-men does not end well.

US MILITARY IS COMPLICIT IN ILLEGAL ACTIONS

It’s clear that the overwhelming majority of the US military – from top to bottom – go along with this war. They do so knowing it’s illegal, that they are actively taking part in a crime, that it’s profoundly misguided, and that a ground invasion will be a costly death trap. Why? Are they not trained to set international law and ethics above orders? My guess is they are not. They are trained in an authoritarian system that sets loyalty above anything else. (As far as I understand, in the Norwegian military, they are trained and encouraged to disobey clearly illegal and unethical orders.)

WITHDRAWING FROM NATO

The Trump administration is getting closer to withdrawing from NATO. That has been Trump’s inclination and aim for years now, and it’s is yet another reason why Europe and European countries cannot rely on the US. They need to forge strong alliances among themselves and with other countries around the world, and detach from reliance on US military support, technology, and so on. Even if Trump will be gone, the dynamics that brought him to power will not. The US cannot be relied on anymore.

THE DYNAMICS THAT LED TO TRUMP’S PRESIDENCY

The Iran debacle is not really about Trump. It’s about the many in the US population who voted for him, knowing very well he is a con man and has no real interest in the well-being of the US population or anyone besides himself. He is a symptom of much deeper dynamics and problems in the US, created by decades of neo-liberal policies aimed at funneling money and resources to the already very wealthy and away from the general population. This has created an understandable and profound mistrust in mainstream politicians, whether they are Democrats or Republicans. Combine this with poor education, a flawed two-party system, and an empire in decline, and you get trouble.

NO REGIME CHANGE THROUGH AIR STRIKES ALONE

Back to the Iran situation, anyone with a basic knowledge of history and the situation would know that… (a) You can’t get regime change through air strikes, it has never happened. (b) The Iranian regime has prepared for this for decades and have a large number of people ready to take over if or when leaders are taken out. (c) Iran can easily make the Hormuz Strait unsafe for traffic and effectively control it. (d) It’s almost impossible to make passage through the Hormuz Strait safe if Iran decides to make it unsafe. (e) This situation gives Iran a massive advantage and leverage. (f) A regime change requires ground invasion, which will be disastrous and immensely costly in terms of lives and resources. (g) There is no simple win here for the US. (h) Which is why no previous US president has been misguided enough to try it.

PAINTED HIMSELF INTO A CORNER

Still in the first week of April, it seems clear that Trump has painted himself into a corner, against the advice of just about anyone who knows the situation. There are no easy solutions. He may well choose a ground invasion, another step of the escalation trap, and this too has no simple or easy resolution. They will face a million soldiers, a country that has prepared for such an invasion for decades, and a massive and challenging geography. History shows that it’s not a good idea to invade Persia or Iran. It rarely if ever goes well for those who try to do so.

GENOCIDAL INTENT

It’s April 7, and Trump is threatening massive attacks on Iranian infrastructure. That is clearly illegal according to international law. It’s a war crime. By saying he will destroy the Iranian/Persian civilization, he displays genocidal intent, which is also a crime. Anyone who participates in this is a war criminal (the Rome Statute), including the soldiers. As so often, much of mainstream media ignores that side of it. For instance, Michael Clarke in this Sky News commentary only focuses on the feasibility of this war crime.

THE OUTCOME SO FAR

April 9 with a tenuous ceasefire and clearly different views of what it entails. What’s clear is the outcome so far: (a) Iran has a more extreme leadership, and one that’s more likely to want nuclear weapons. (The former leaders were far less inclined to want it.) (b) Iran has played their Strait of Hormuz card, which everyone knew they had, and has control over a significant part of the world economy. (c) The US and Israel has weakened support internationally, and deepened the (understandable) hatred many in the region has towards them. (d) Iran is more motivated to seek and deepen alliances with other enemies of the US and/or Israel. And, as we also knew before this started, (e) regime change cannot happen through air strikes alone, and (f) a ground invasion will be enormously costly in terms of resources, human lives, and damage to the US/Israeli international relations.

NO EASY WINS

April 11. Trump has and will continue to fail in Iran. There are no easy ways out for him. So he needs – psychologically and politically – an easy win somewhere else. That makes him even more dangerous on the international scene. He may, in his derangement, take it out on Greenland, Cuba, or another country he thinks he can easily dominate.

IRAN GAINS STRENGTH AND MONEY

April 12. Predictably, the negotiations failed. Iran is in a much stronger position now than before the war, largely through demonstrating that they can easily close the Strait of Hormuz. That means they can demand more, and that’s not acceptable for Trump’s ego. Trump has now closed the strait (!), which seems another childish move. “You are not closing it, I am closing it!”. As before, there is no easy way out of this for Trump and the US. That’s why no previous US president has been stupid enough to go to war against Iran. It’s a losing proposition no matter how you look at it.

As a reminder, before the US/Israeli war against Iran, Iran… Was not interested in developing nuclear weapons, for religious reasons. (Now, they are far more motivated to develop nuclear weapons.) Was open for nuclear inspectors. Did not block the Strait of Hormuz. Had more moderate politicians at the top. (Now killed by the US/Israel.) Had agreed to a plan with Biden, which Trump tore up.

In short, this debacle is all created by Trump and Netanyahu. It has worsened the situation dramatically for all parties and the world in general, and there is no easy way out. Both were predicted, and has been predicted for years and even decades. Trump finds himself in the escalation trap. Even if he somehow would declare victory and pull out, the situation will be worse than before. In either case, he may be motivated to seek a more easy “win” somewhere else – for instance, by invading Cuba.

THE ESCALATION TRAP

It’s April 15, and Robert Pape again speaks about the escalation trap based on his three decades of studies. Iran is only getting stronger (they have shown they can block the Strait of Hormuz), more motivated to have nuclear weapons (the moderates were killed), and is deepening its ties with China, Russia, and other enemies of the US. Trump has a choice between (a) making concessions and allowing Iran to become a stronger power in the world, and (b) tanking the world economy through continued blockades. (Short term.)

OBAMA’S AGREEMENT WITH IRAN

Obama’s agreement with Iran could have and did prevent all this. Trump tore it up (his fragile sense of self-worth was too threatened by a smart black man) and instead started a doomed war which will either (a) make Iran far more powerful or (b) lead to an immensely costly and drawn out ground war with no guaranteed outcomes. (Long term.)

A LARGE SCALE GROUND WAR WILL BE IMMENSELY COSTLY

When it comes to a large scale ground war, Iran has roughly 1 million soldiers, which means a successful large scale successful ground invasion will require a huge number of US/Israeli soldiers. (Likely at least the same number, ideally 3-4 times that.) That seems unlikely, so a ground war will probably be smaller scale and won’t achieve much.

THE US CANNOT BE TRUSTED

Another long term outcome of this is that the world sees two things. (a) The US cannot be trusted. Nobody can trust the US, not even its traditional allies. Trump is not the problem here, deeper dynamics in the US are and they won’t go away. (b) If you have nuclear weapons, you are relatively safe. If you don’t – like Iran, Venezuela, Cuba, Greenland/Denmark, and so on – you are not safe. By tearing up agreements and starting unprovoked wars, the US has shown it cannot be trusted, and nuclear weapons is the way to go if you want to prevent an attack.

ISRAEL LOSES ALLIES AND CREATES ENEMIES

When it comes to Israel, it’s difficult to understand how (a) an ongoing UN defined genocide and (b) an unprovoked, illegal, and doomed attack on Iran are going to help them. It will only turn the international community away from and against them. As described above, this attack on Iran will only strengthen Iran and encourage them to develop nuclear weapons. The alternative is an enormously costly and drawn out ground invasion, which may even fail – or lead to a further destabilized West Asia.

Before this war, the leadership in Iran was against developing nuclear weapons for religious and practical reasons. Now, they have every incentive to develop nuclear weapons. How is that going to help Israel? It seems suicidal, and it seems like a misguided and harmful trauma response. Hurt people (sometimes) hurt people, and in the process hurt themselves.

WIN-WIN VS ZERO-SUM

April 19. In general, all of this – the Iran war, Israel’s genocide, Putin’s invasion of Ukraine – seems profoundly misguided to most Europeans and many around the world. There main reason may be a difference between a win-win versus zero-sum mindset.

Trump, Netanyahu, and Putin all come from a zero-sum and authoritarian mindset. They see alliances as weak. They want sole power. They want yes-men around them. They don’t listen to actual experts. That’s the reason for their decisions and behavior, and it leads to misguided actions – including the Iran war, Israel’s genocide, the Putin’s invasion of Ukraine. Europe in general has more of a win-win mindset. We seek alliances. We know we are stronger together. We seek to strengthen bonds and ties. We seek diplomatic solutions.

To be fair, we have to seek alliances since we are small alone. That’s the gift in being relatively small. The curse of large countries is that the leaders, and sometimes the population, can get into the illusion that they are more powerful than they are. They think they can go alone and others will fold. And that’s not how the world works.

WITH TRUMP, WE ALL LOSE

Trump likely wants to get out of the Iran war, although it’s difficult to see how he can get out of it. Iran can demand far more than they could before this war, and that may be difficult for Trump to swallow.

If Trump can get out while maintaining the illusion of victory and control, he will leave Iran in a much stronger position. Also, it may lead to Trump wanting an “easy” win somewhere else – likely Cuba first, then possibly Greenland, or other countries. In any case, the world loses.

NUANCE

This writing is in the form of journal entries. I don’t try to make it very nuanced, and I have no intention of convincing anyone of anything. It’s more just how it comes out at a very human and personal level, and it reflects my own background, views, and biases. At the same time, I think that much, if not most, will hold up in hindsight.

THE WAR PRESIDENT

Trump 1.0 wasn’t exactly a peace president, but he didn’t start foreign wars. Trump 2.0 was always going to be different. He changed a lot in the years between. In November 2024, after he was elected and before he started his second term, I wrote this in Trump’s victory: the empire strikes back:

“We don’t know what wars Trump may start, possibly in an attempt to distract from unpopular policies and unite the US population behind him. He avoided wars during the first presidency, but Trump 2.0 will be different.”

The likelihood of Trump-initiated wars was clear during his campaign for the second term, so I don’t know why some still saw him as a peace president, or now seem surprised by the Iran war and his threats against traditional allies like Canada and Greenland/Denmark. I guess they haven’t paid attention.

INSIDER TRADING

April 20. There has been a pretty clear pattern of insider trading over the last few weeks. Minutes before Trump announces yet another reversal, there is a flurry of trade in petroleum stocks and someone makes a windfall. It is mentioned in mainstream media, as in the BBC story I linked to above. At the same time, it’s not getting the attention it deserves, likely because it’s just one more example of systematic corruption and crimes committed by Trump and his associates. It’s what we have come to expect.

SANEWASHING

I have been slightly baffled by the sanewashing of Trump by mainstream media, especially during his first term. He is clearly unhinged and has major mental problems, and the media seems to have seen it as their job to make him look more coherent and sane than he is.

I am not sure why. If I was a reporter, I would make it my job to present it clearly since it is a major public concern, both within the US and for the rest of the world. It impacts all of us.

That mostly continued for the first year of his second term (last year), and now, there seems to be more stories in mainstream media calling out his unhinged behavior. For instance, ABC News (Australia) has this story: Trump’s erratic actions spark speculation on cognitive decline.

What’s slightly odd about this is that his bizarre behavior has been on display the whole time, and now they are talking about cognitive decline, as if that’s the main story.

OPPOSED TO THE US – OR EMPIRE, AUTHORITARIANISM, AND OLIGARCHY?

I see that more people seem to side with Iran and China over the last few weeks. That’s also slightly baffling to me. Yes, Trump and the US are committing crimes, Trump has stated genocidal intent, the war is profoundly misguided even from a practical point of view, Israel is committing systematic genocide and very likely convinced Trump to start the Iran war, and so on. That’s all terrible.

That doesn’t make Iran or China the “good guys” or someone to side with. They are doing much of the same, and sometimes worse. They are oppressive regimes with a history of major human rights violations, and they are both far more undemocratic than the US currently is. (Of course, Trump would like the US to be more authoritarian.)

Personally, I am for democracy, human rights, social justice, and so on. And I don’t care much for oligarchies, authoritarian regimes, human rights violations, and similar.

If you side with Iran and China (or Putin’s Russia), you are in effect saying: I am fine with human rights violations and authoritarian and oppressive regimes, as long as it’s not the US. That doesn’t make much sense to me.

*** MY OWN BIAS & THE BIGGER PICTURE ***

I am acutely aware that all of this reflects my own bias and my own culture. I am typical Norwegian in these views – at least, typical for a university educated Norwegian who cares about people and the world. My views are typical for an educated liberal person alive in the late 1900s and early 2000s.

I have intentionally written this from my more unfiltered humanity, to acknowledge that side of me too.

And I also know that this – what I write about – is all part of the human experiment. It’s part of the unfolding of this living planet. It’s an expression of Existence as a whole. These too are local and temporary expressions of the dynamics of the whole of Existence. It’s all life, the universe, existence, the divine expressing, exploring, and experiencing itself in always new ways.

It’s one chapter in the unfolding of humanity and this living planet. Humanity itself is one chapter of the unfolding of this seamless living system we call Earth. Earth itself is one chapter in the unfolding of this seamless system we call the Universe.

THE UPSIDES & FUNCTION OF DOMINATION CULTURE

In the bigger picture, there is clearly a function to domination culture and empire. The dominance of domination culture is a phase in the unfolding of human culture. It comes with many downsides, and also many upsides – in terms of developing art, science, technology, philosophy, and so on.

Is this the chapter that brings about the end of human culture or humanity itself? If so, it’s just still one of many chapters in the history of this living planet, and there will be many more chapters to come – likely with amazing things we cannot even begin to imagine.

Or will there be more chapters in human civilization? If so, will the next be more of a balance between partnership and domination orientation? Will it be one of a deep partnership with life, and with our past history of partnership and domination – taking the best from both and creating something new?

MAY

It’s now May, and the situation is unfolding much as experts predicted. Iran has prepared for this for decades. That means they have people ready to replace leaders, they are able to secure weapons and nuclear production from strikes, and they are able to strike back at US bases in the region. The US rapidly depleted their weapons supply. A large scale ground war is doomed to fail and/or become a long and terrible quagmire. The Hormuz Strait has become a Mexican standoff with no solution in sight.

From all of this, Iran is emerging stronger, and the shortcomings of military might in complex situations is becoming evident. Trump is flailing since there are no good solutions for him.

This is still the essence of the situation: (a) Iran controls the Strait of Hormuz and, with it, petroleum-derived chemicals needed for artificial fertilizers (which impacts the world’s food production since it’s made dependent on those fertilizers) and 20% of the world’s petroleum. (b) There is no reason to assume that will change. The US does not have the capacity to prevent Iran from attacking ships in the strait. (c) Iran sits with the strongest hand at the negotiating table, and even if the demands they make are reasonable, Trump’s fragile ego is unable to accept it. (d) Even if Trump pulled out while declaring victory, this will not change Iran’s control of the strait. (e) Only a massive ground invasion will have a chance of stopping Iran’s control of the strait, and it will be immensely costly and drawn out, and not even be certain to succeed. (f) This was all known and predicted before the war, which is why no US president has done it before.

VIDEOS

These videos are obviously biased against the war. At the same time, they are grounded in an understanding of history and social dynamics. I am mostly including them to show that what likely happens in the coming weeks, months, and years was predicted at the beginning of this war, and even before. Some are interviews with Robert Pape who has studied the escalation trap for three decades.

First week: Iran and the escalation trap – Front Burner | The Billionaire Oligarchs Pushing For War With Iran | ‘Iran is Not Gaza’ Acclaimed Writer Arundhati Roy | Rambling inconsistent nonsense”. Does Donald Trump have a plan in Iran? | Iran Is The Beginning Of The End For Trump | How Iran war may accelerate the fall of US empire – Soumaya Ghannoushi MEE Opinion | The History of Iran and Winston Churchill Exposes How the Past Repeats Itself

Second week: Er Pete Hegseth på korstog? MAGAWATCH | The Iran War Expert: I Simulated The Iran War for 20 Years. Here’s What Happens Next

Third week: Why Game Theory Predicts a Long War in Iran | Yanis Varoufakis: ‘Nothing Can Save’ Trump From Iran War Disaster | Professor Pape: Why Iran Ground Invasion Is Likely Coming | John Mearsheimer: Trump’s War Is Strategic Disaster W/ No End In Sight | Trump is Completely Stuck in Iran Right Now | Trump’s Iran strategy is ‘very weird’, says Rory Stewart

Fourth week: Does Trump regret the war in Iran? – World Politics – The New Statesman | Are the US and Israel actively seeking an off-ramp for the Iran war? – DW News | Why “Boots on the Ground” Suddenly Looks Inevitable

April I: Is the U.S. about to make a major military mistake? – About That | Why is it so difficult to open the Strait of Hormuz? | Professor Pape: Iran war not over, Trump trapped | Trump’s Illegalist War Gets Illegaler | The Moment the US Lost Its Superpower Status and Iran Became More Powerful Than Ever Before | Professor Pape: Trump Ceasefire Will Fail As War Metastasizes | Professor Robert Pape: US Has No Idea What is Coming Next

April II: Iran Is Becoming “Fourth World Power” Now – w/ Robert Pape | Why Another US Attempt on Greenland Looks Worryingly Inevitable | The insider trading suspicions looming over Trump’s presidency – BBC News | Trump’s erratic actions spark speculation on cognitive decline – ABC News | Why Trump’s missile math doesn’t work – CBC News

May: Iran ‘will not capitulate’, conflict resolution expert says – France 24 | How is a depleted Iran damaging so many US bases? A CNN investigation | Hegseth’s holy war – Vox | Majority of US military sites in Middle East damaged by Iran – CNN | Robert Kagan on why he believes U.S. faces likely defeat in Iran – PBS Newshour |

Read More

The success paradox: When we are blind to the problems we no longer have and what prevents them from returning

This is an example of the success paradox – also known as the prevention paradox or historical amnesia.

It’s a common and serious problem in our society.

WHAT IT IS?

The success paradox happens when we have succeeded reducing or eliminating a social problem, we forget about the problem and why it’s gone, and set out to dismantle the social systems and institutions that eliminated the problem, allowing the problem to return.

We see this today with vaccines, democracy, taxes, unions, pandemic measures, inclusivity policies, and much more.

WHY DOES IT HAPPEN?

I suspect it happens for several reasons.

The problems are no longer in living memory. If those who experienced it are no longer alive, they can’t warn us.

There is a lack of knowledge of history. Some see history as irrelevant or boring, so they didn’t pay attention in school, and don’t set out to educate themselves.

Some act out of narrow self-interest. This may be because of a challenging life situation, or reactivity from wounding, so they seek scapegoats, the promise of simple solutions, and so on.

This is all fueled by social media and sometimes media figures and politicians. In some cases, the dis- and misinformation is financed and fueled by Big Money.

WHAT CAN WE DO ABOUT IT?

For ourselves, we can educate ourselves about past problems, how they were lessened or solved, and what in our systems today prevent them from returning. There is no lack of information out there in the form of articles, books, historical fiction movies, documentaries, and so on. Just make sure it comes from reliable sources, including serious historians.

It’s obviously more tricky to resolve it at a social level.

Media literacy and critical thinking needs to be emphasized in schools, by responsible media, and needs to be part of the public discourse.

Good social safety nets helps people feel more safe, trust society more, and be less reactive.

Social media can have, as they sometimes do, automatic comments on content that’s misleading or on an often misrepresented issue.

It also helps to point out the real causes of people’s problems, which are often systemic and because Big Money benefit from it. (It’s almost never because of some minority group, or scientists, or experts of any kind, or even politicians.)

SOME EXAMPLES

Vaccines are an obvious example. Many diseases are eradicated or rare today because of vaccines, so most have no personal experience with them, don’t realize how terrible they were, and think eliminating vaccines is a good idea. If they had more personal experience with the diseases, they would probably see it differently.

In the Western world, almost everyone alive today have only lived in a democracy. It’s all we have personally known. It’s easy to take it for granted, and be seduced by authoritarian politicians who promise simple solutions to complex problems. If democracy is dismantled in the process, it may – to some – seem a small price to pay. They would likely see it very differently if they had known authoritarian and totalitarian regimes from their own experience. Even if you think you are in the “safe” group in such a society, you can easily find yourself among the targeted. Fascism eats its own.

In the US, there is a strong movement to undermine and dismantle unions, and to prevent new ones from forming. This comes from Big Money, although many in society in general seems to support it. They may not know that much of what we enjoy in our work-life today comes directly from the work of unions, and that it may never have happened without unions: The eight-hour workday, the weekend, overtime pay, safer workplaces, child labor laws, higher wages, health insurance and pensions, paid leave, protection against unfair firing and discrimination, and much more.

Some seem to dislike taxes, perhaps without realizing their many benefits to society as a whole and for us as individuals. Without taxes, there would be no functional society. We may not agree with how the money is distributed, or what exactly is taxed, but it’s important to remember that this society would not be here without taxes. It’s how we pay for everything we collectively benefit from, including a relatively well-functioning and safe society.

These days, there is also an anti-woke movement. I wonder if these people know how important it is for society as a whole to make inclusivity structural. Again, we may not agree with all the details, but the general movement in that direction is essential for a well-functioning society that works for all of us.

Read More

What do Germans think about the current situation in the US?

What do Germans think about the current situation in the US? A German YouTuber living in the US asked her audience. Her videos are typically a-political (on language and culture), so it’s interesting to see what her likely quite general audience says.

In my experience, the comments reflect what most Europeans think about what’s happening in the US.

To me, it’s also a reminder of what I noticed when I moved to the US in the ’90s. Most Europeans seem far better informed about what’s happening in the US than most people living in the US.

How to deal with a bully

The response, meanwhile, by Democrats has been unconscionably weak. It’s no coincidence that governors like Gavin Newsom and J.B. Pritzker have been the leaders of recent days; they are clear-eyed about what is happening. As Greg Sargent writes, “Newsom shapes everything around the brute fact that Trump is serially breaking the law and using government sponsored violence and intimidation to entrench authoritarian power. He accepts this as the core fact of our moment.”

By contrast, I challenge you to find even a moderately tepid and clear-eyed statement from any national Democrat. National Democrats seem all invisible as the military takes over policing the streets of the capital and prosecuting its crimes. This should be a lay-up to oppose — the most basic duty of any congressional figure, and yet, “House Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries and Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer, along with other senior Democrats, have not been a part of any concerted effort to voice opposition to the occupation.”

– from Slouching Into Fascism by Garrett Graff, Mother Jones

One thing that’s been increasingly clear over the years – if it wasn’t already – is that many mainstream Western politicians don’t know how to fight a bully.

PUTIN

When Putin invaded Ukraine, I was baffled when Western countries did not offer full weapons support for Ukraine with no strings attached. They purposely limited Ukraine’s ability to fight back, which has led to a long, costly, and drawn out war with an uncertain outcome.

The explicit reason was that they didn’t want to provoke Putin further. That’s an example of a hesitant response to bullies, and one that the bully – in this case Putin – tends to see as a sign of weakness and be encouraged by. (I suspect there was another reason for limiting Ukraine’s ability to fight back. They wanted to drain Russia’s military resources and weaken Russia in general, even if it comes at the cost of death and enormous suffering, the possibility of Ukraine losing the war, and the encouragement of Putin’s imperial ambitions.)

TRUMP

We see something similar with how the Democratic leadership, with a few exceptions, have dealt with the Republicans, especially since the tea party era of the 2000s. The Republicans play dirty and have thrown out the rule book, and the Democratic leadership acts as if nothing has changed and everyone still plays by the old rules. They have, in practice, rolled over and allowed the Republicans to get what they want.

The Democrats had control of Congress and the White House and chose to not eliminate the filibuster. (Due to pressure from within their own party.) That allowed the Republicans to block voter rights legislation and more. Trump was impeached twice, and the Democrats chose to not forcefully push for consequences. Biden and the Democrats chose to not expand the Supreme Court, even if the Republicans had already politicized the court to an extreme.

When Harris became the Democratic candidate last summer, she and Walz used a more direct and effective verbal strategy for some weeks – fighting dirty, ridiculing Trump, and calling him out for what he is. That worked and they gained in the polls. Then, for some inexplicable reason, they went back to the “high ground” approach and lost traction.

Now, it seems that some Democrats are again growing a spine, especially Gavin Newsom and some other Democratic governors. Newsom aims to redistrict California to mirror what the Republicans are doing in Texas. He has run ads in Republican-led states mocking conservative leaders, and he is mimicking Trump’s own slogans and style to expose their absurdity. If it’s ridiculous when Newsom does it, what does it say about the president? We’ll have to see if it continues, and if others join him and the other governors.

HOW TO DEAL WITH A BULLY

In some cases, it is possible that being polite, playing by the rules, and treating bullies with respect may work. It’s rare, but it may happen, especially if the bullying behavior is not deeply ingrained in the personality of the bully.

But in most cases, bullies need to be met with actions and a language they understand. As Newsom says, we have to fight fire with fire. They have to be met with strength and consequences, and that’s best done when we strategize and coordinate our efforts. It’s scary to stand up to a bully, so it’s better done together.

History shows us that appeasing authoritarians rarely works. We know that from 1930s Europe, and we see it again today.

WHY AM I CONCERNED ABOUT THIS?

Why am I concerned about this? After all, I don’t live in the US, I live in a functioning democracy, and I don’t seem directly impacted by any of this.

It’s partly because I experienced bullying as a kid, and I have seen what it does to people. Authoritarians are bullies, just on a national and international scale. Our political views inevitably reflect personal experiences and concerns.

Democracies are eroding around the world these days. Current democracies are far from perfect, but they are the best we have, they can improve, and they are far better than the alternatives.

Even if I happened to agree with some of the policies of an authoritarian leader, I would still far prefer a flawed democracy with leaders I don’t necessarily agree with. At least then, there is the possibility of peaceful course correction coming from the people.

I don’t live in the US anymore, but as someone said: When the US sneezes, the world catches a cold. What happens in the US tends to impact the rest of the world, both directly through US foreign policies, and indirectly by people in other countries mimicking – and also responding to – what happens in the US.

I live in Norway, a neighbor of Russia, and I know Russia’s historical imperial ambitions and how Putin have adopted those for himself. If Putin gets his way with Ukraine, there is no reason to assume he will stop there.

Fascism eats its own

Tony Gilroy, the writer and producer for Star Wars: Andor, here mentions that fascism eats its own.

That’s very clear from history, from any authoritarian regime, which is why it’s so puzzling to me that people vote for authoritarianism/fascism, and why people chose to get involved in an even more direct and intimate way.

More to the point these days: Why did people vote for Trump, when his policies will likely harm them? Why do people chose to get involved with Trump more directly, when they’ll likely get chewed up and spit out?

There is no one simple answer, of course.

Some may have voted for him because they are fed misinformation from Fox News and social media. They may not know much about project 2025 and what it means for them. They think bad things will happen to others, not them. They don’t know much about history and similar projects in the past and how it played itself out.

Some may choose to get involved because it seems the safest at the moment. It just requires yielding to pressure and do what the strong man says. They think they’ll somehow be protected and get away with it. (Which may happen, but it’s equally likely they’ll get eaten by the dynamics of fascism.) Maybe they like the gamble. Maybe they felt safer on the side of the strong man in childhood, or wanted a strong man in their life to protect them.

Note: I use “strong man” in invisible quotation marks here. Trump and similar authoritarians try to develop the image of a strong man which reveals a deep insecurity. Someone with real confidence don’t need to do it. Many see through this, but not all.

A few resources to understand Trump’s authoritarian takeover

I thought I would share a few resources I find helpful in understanding what’s going on in the US these days, especially considering that mainstream media often gloss over, avoid, or whitewash some of the most important points.

NEWS, ANALYSIS AND COMMENTARIES

News Sources

The Guardian – often very good

ProPublica – investigative journalism

BBC | PBS | NPR | CBC | 60 Minutes Australia – more mainstream, sometimes good

Magazines

The Atlantic | Teen Vogue | The New Yorker

Commentators, Historians, Journalists

Robert Reich – political commentator | website | youtube

Heather Cox Richardson – historian | youtube | substack

Anne Applebaum – historian | website | The Atlantic

Timothy Snyder – historian of fascism and democracy | youtube | On Tyranny (article)

Katie Couric – journalist | website | youtube

LegalEagle – a law perspective on Trump’s actions | youtube

Russel Razzaque – London-based psychiatrist | website | youtube

Parkrose Permaculture – insightful commentary | youtube

This is an incomplete and random list, and highlights some resources I find helpful.

FICTION

I am watching Andor (Star Trek series) and am reminded of how fiction often gets to the crucial points better than much current affairs media. I am in the middle of the current season. A central theme is how the empire is using resistance as an excuse to take even more drastic measures to take and maintain control, all for the purpose of funneling more money, resources, and power to the already very wealthy at the expense of everyone else. (I found a short clip where the writer of Andor, Tony Gilroy, talks about Star Wars and fascism, commenting on how fascism inevitably eats its own.)

That’s what we are seeing in Los Angeles these days. People are protesting against the inhumane tactics used by ICE. Trump is using it as an excuse to mobilize the National Guard (which he is not allowed to) and the marines to squash any protests in the streets. And the real purpose is to further consolidate power, normalizing using the National Guard and the US military against US citizens, and further intimidate the population and quiet dissent.

This is straight out of the fascist playbook, has been predicted for months, and is one more step in the classic fascist takeover.

IT’S NOT ABOUT TRUMP

This is not really about Trump. It’s far deeper than that. It’s about Project 2025. It’s a culmination of the climate and indoctrination created by Fox News for decades. It’s about the many who voted for Trump because they are scared of losing their (perceived) white privilege. It’s about all social commentators who, for decades, have pitted groups against each other to distract from what’s really going on: funneling even more money and resources to the already extremely wealthy. It’s about decades of neoliberal policies aimed at doing exactly that.

Even more crucially and fundamentally, it’s about domination culture.

This is one of the many expressions of domination culture.

I have found Riane Eisler and Starhawk helpful here, and I know there are many others talking and writing about this topic.

Vance, Prevost, and a zero-sum vs win-win orientation

JD Vance has said that Christian love means to prioritize your family, then community, then country, and last the rest of the world.

Before he became Pope Leo XIV, Prevost tweeted the reply above, reminding Vance and others that love cannot be ranked.

THE TWO VIEWS

I came across someone talking about this. He said that the views reflect the difference between (a) our fallible human tendency to prioritize those close to us versus (b) the ideal of loving everyone equally. To me, that’s missing the mark.

It’s not fallible to prioritize those close to us. It makes sense to do so since we are in the best position, perhaps among everyone, to make a difference to those close to us.

It’s also not an ideal to love all equally, it’s what we are and it doesn’t go counter to prioritizing those close to us.

ZERO-SUM VS WIN-WIN

To me, the two views – of Vance and Prevost – are really about the difference between a zero-sum and a win-win orientation.

Zero-sum

Trump, Vance, and MAGA tend to operate from a zero-sum view of the world.

If you win, it likely means that I – somehow, even if I don’t know how yet – will lose.

Similarly, I’ll seek out ways to win that makes sure that you lose. That’s the only way I can be sure I won.

We see this in just about all aspects of Trump’s policies, and this is very far from the life and words of Jesus.

It’s also very far from the reality of a profoundly interconnected world, a world that’s one seamless system where the health and well-being of the larger whole is profoundly interconnected with my own health and well-being.

Win-win

Prevost seems to come from more of a win-win orientation, and an orientation more aligned with the life and words of Jesus.

He knows that we can find solutions that benefit us and our families, and also the larger social and ecological whole. He knows we can find, chose, and live win-win solutions.

We can take care of our families, communities, and country, and do so in a way that also benefits the wider world, the living web we are part of, and future generations.

For me, that’s the essence of the difference in view between Vance and Prevost.

DOMINATION VS PARTNERSHIP LENS

There is a lot more to say about this, and I have written about it in other articles.

Trump and Vance’s view is an expression of a strong and relatively one-sided domination culture. Central to that culture is a view of separation, zero-sum strategies, either-or thinking, and so on.

Trauma is also central to that culture. Collective and intergenerational trauma is part of how it perpetuates itself, and a zero-sum orientation is – in many ways – a trauma response.

Although Prevost is part of an institution that has strong domination culture elements (a history of supporting fascist regimes, strong patriarchical hierarchy, an idea of the sacred as “out there”, dogmas you are supposed to pretend to “believe” in, colonialism/missionary work, and so on), he and the Catholic Church has elements of a partnership orientation, as expressed in his tweet.

Although that’s another topic for another time, there is a fundamental dissonance in the Catholic Church. As an institution, it’s an expression of a strong domination culture that far too often sides with the powerful. It’s supposedly built on the teachings and life of Jesus, who had a radical partnership orientation. And to acknowledge that, they need to soften their edges a bit and bring in some elements of a partnership orientation.

Video: History professor answers dictator questions – Wired

Dictators who take your rights away want more than just your silence—they want your complicity. They want you to betray other people in your communities, to inform on them, to look the other way when your loved ones are taken by the secret police. But more than that, they want you to betray yourself. They want you to lose your moral compass. They want you to self-censor.

Dictators are very skilled at posing as saviors. They create crises—or exploit existing ones—and then present themselves as the only solution. Whether it’s an economic collapse or a perceived threat of social unrest, they step in with promises of order and protection.

One of the classic dictator narratives for the past hundred years is this: only the authoritarian leader can keep people safe from immigrants crossing the border. There’s always a grain of truth—they come over the border, yes—but dictators twist that truth. They say immigrants are coming to rape our women, to steal our jobs, to dilute the population with the “wrong” skin color or faith.

These same excuses have been used for generations to justify national purity campaigns. Mussolini, for example, talked about Black, brown, and yellow people—his words—coming across the border and having too many babies. These are old narratives, but they still work. Why? Because they make people afraid—afraid for their safety, their families, their way of life. And in that fear, the dictator says: “I alone can fix it.”

– Ruth Ben-Ghiat in History Professor Answers Dictator Questions

A clear and concise summary of some of the features of authoritarianism and dictatorships. Of course, it’s not a coincidence that this comes out now, a few weeks into Trump’s second term.

Personally, I have a few different things come up around this. Yes, I know people repeat history, including the type of history that is harmful to themselves. Yes, I know many – especially in the US it seems – don’t know much history. (This is partly by design since some political groups benefit from an uneducated population.) Yes, I know that not everyone had the same education and grew up in the same culture as me. (Learning about these kinds of things were central to my middle school education, and it’s part of Norwegian culture since we lived through a dictatorship during WW2.)

And yet, a part of me is baffled. Isn’t this obvious? No, apparently it’s not. Apparently, people need to make the same mistakes again, and again. I guess that’s a feature of this world that’s inherently changing, unpredictable, and has a mix of things our personalities likes and don’t like.

I asked AI about Trump, Project 2025, and likely scenarios for the coming months and years

We are three weeks into Trump’s second term. I asked ChatGPT 4o for input on Trump and Project 2025, and a few related topics. See below.

  1. How Trump’s Actions Align with Project 2025 and What to Expect Next
  2. What We Can Expect From Trump in the Coming Months and Years
  3. The Consequences of Trump’s Policies: Democracy, Economy, Health, and Everyday Life
  4. The Culture War as a Distraction from the Class War
  5. How a Weakened Education System Helps the Far Right and Republicans
  6. Why Do People Vote Against Their Own Interests? The Trump Phenomenon Explained
  7. What Did the Democrats Do Wrong? Why Didn’t They Focus on the Class War?
  8. The Effects on the Relationships with Traditionally Friendly Countries
  9. Is This the End of the U.S. Empire?
  10. The Consequences of Growing Economic Inequality in the U.S.: Scenarios and Historical Parallels
  11. The Billionaire Oligarchy Scenario: How the U.S. Becomes a Corporate Feudal State
  12. Why Do Trump, Musk, and the People Behind Project 2025 Want This to Happen?
  13. What May Happen to Ordinary Citizens in Trump’s America?
  14. Is Any of This Surprising? Didn’t Voters Know This Would Happen?
  15. Best-Case vs. Most Likely Scenario for the U.S. Moving Forward
  16. Global Consequences of the U.S. Becoming a Billionaire Oligarchy
  17. How Accurate Is This Analysis? How Biased Is It?

How Trump’s Actions Align with Project 2025 and What to Expect Next

As of February 16, 2025, President Donald Trump’s actions have closely aligned with the conservative policy blueprint known as Project 2025, despite his previous campaign disavowal of the plan. In his initial days in office, Trump issued a series of executive orders, with analyses indicating that nearly two-thirds mirror or partially mirror proposals from Project 2025. Time

Alignment with Project 2025:

  • Federal Workforce Overhaul: Trump established the Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE), led by Elon Musk, aiming to reduce government waste and streamline operations. This initiative reflects Project 2025’s goal to restructure the federal workforce and eliminate perceived inefficiencies. New York Post
  • Energy Policies: The creation of the National Energy Dominance Council and actions to boost oil and gas production align with Project 2025’s emphasis on achieving energy independence through deregulation and increased domestic energy production. AP News
  • Education and Social Policies: Trump’s executive order to cut off federal funding for educational institutions enforcing COVID-19 vaccine mandates, along with efforts to dismantle diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI) programs, correspond with Project 2025’s recommendations to limit federal involvement in education and social policies. The Guardian

Exceeding Project 2025:

In some areas, Trump’s actions have gone beyond the original recommendations of Project 2025:

  • Foreign Aid Reduction: The administration has moved to dismantle the U.S. Agency for International Development (USAID), a step more drastic than those proposed in Project 2025. Reuters
  • Civil Service Restructuring: Mass firings of federal employees and the implementation of loyalty tests represent a more aggressive approach than outlined in Project 2025, aiming to reshape the civil service fundamentally. The Atlantic

Projected Trajectory:

If President Trump continues on this trajectory, we can anticipate several developments in the coming months and years:

  • Consolidation of Executive Power: Ongoing efforts to centralize authority within the executive branch may lead to significant shifts in the balance of power among federal institutions.
  • Judicial Appointments: Expect a continued focus on appointing judges who align with the administration’s ideology, potentially influencing the judiciary’s independence and decisions on key issues.
  • Policy Implementation Challenges: The administration is likely to face legal challenges and pushback from various sectors, including civil rights groups, environmental organizations, and international allies, in response to its aggressive policy changes.

These anticipated actions suggest a transformative period in U.S. governance, with potential long-term implications for domestic policies and international relations.

Trump’s Rapid Policy Moves Stir Controversy

Read More

Dream: I sense the distress of large numbers of people impacted by Trump’s policies

I sense the suffering of large numbers of people impacted by Trump’s policies. Thousands if not millions of people. I see them, hear their voices, sense their distress. I hear voices say “DEI hires”.

The sensing here is the same as when I sense the system of others during healing, whether it’s my natural form of healing or more structured through Vortex Healing.

For all I know, this experience may be a combination of actual sensing and a dream.

COMPENSATION

As I woke up, the first that came to mind is that this dream is a compensation for the insensitivity and cruelty of Trump and the ones supporting his policies.

They seem to lack empathy, so I find it here. It becomes more important for me.

My mind brought me this dream to find a deeper and more visceral empathy, to compensate for the lack of empathy among some others – especially the ones creating, implementing, and supporting Trump’s policies.

EMPATHY FOR TRUMP AND HIS SUPPORTERS

For me, it’s also a reminder of finding the same empathy and understanding with Trump and his supporters. Hurt people hurt people. It’s trauma behavior. They are traumatized, and they deal with it by traumatizing others.

I will speak up about what I see, and would be actively engaged in stopping it if I still lived in the US, and I can also have understanding and empathy for the ones supporting these policies of cruelty.

These two – empathy and engagement – go hand in hand, they mutually support each other. Empathy guides views and actions, and engagement is empathy in action.

FINDING IT ALL IN MYSELF

And it’s a reminder to find it all in myself. I am the ones in distress. I am the one acting without empathy and in cruel ways. In other words, I have distressed parts in me. And I have parts without empathy acting in cruel ways.

What are examples of when I acted in ways that was experienced as cruel by others?

How am I doing it with Trump supporters now? It’s easy to imagine that the way I sometimes see them – as cruel, without empathy, and supporting the transition to a fascist regime – can be experienced as harsh and cruel by some of them. It’s not how they see themselves.

It’s not how they all are, it’s not all of what they are, and if they have that side to them, it comes from traumas and it’s trauma behavior. It comes from living in and being impacted and shaped by a domination culture.

How are parts of me cruel with me? I am cruel with myself when I go into catastrophic images about the future. I am cruel with myself when I exaggerate – to myself or others – challenging situations. I am cruel with myself if I accept situations that seem unjust, that creates more problems for me, and that can be fixed if I speak and stand up for myself.

Really, I am cruel with myself anytime I hold a thought as true and pretend it’s true.

I am cruel anytime I allow myself to get caught up in, or caught up in reactivity to, wounds in me as if what they are telling me is true.

Read More

Perspectives on Trump

Like many others, I have felt a need to process after the re-election of Trump, knowing what he wants to do, and knowing that he this time has plans and people in place to do it. (At least as far as is possible considering that he will receive pushback from democratic institutions and people who still support democracy.)

Here are some of the many perspectives on Trump and his followers that I find useful in that they seem accurate and kind. (Kind to myself!)

HAPPENING WITHIN AND AS WHAT I AM

It’s all happening within and as what I am. That’s the context for it all.

In my own first person experience, I am not most fundamentally this human self, a doer, and observer, or anything else within the content of experience. All of that comes and goes.

I find I more fundamentally am what it all happens within and as. The world, as it appears to me, happens within and as the consciousness I am. It happens within and as the oneness I am.

This is the insight of mystics across traditions and throughout time, and it’s what I find for myself as well.

This is the context of direct noticing.

THE PLAY OF LIFE

In the realm of stories, I can say this another way.

What we see unfolding in the world today is all the play of life.

It’s the unfolding of this universe and this living system we call Earth.

It’s the ephemeral and local expressions of this universe, Earth, and existence.

It’s existence expressing, exploring, and experiencing itself in this way, for a little while and locally here.

This living system we call Earth is expressing, exploring, and experiencing itself as all of this – as social dynamics, Trump, his supporters, those opposing him, me, the thoughts and feelings we have about it, and everything else.

It’s all the play of life. As far as I can tell, the purpose of existence and life is this exploration. It’s life expressing, exploring, and experiencing itself in always new ways, and this is one ephemeral and local way that it does so.

That’s the big picture context within the realm of stories.

SURVIVAL FOCUS, LACK OF EDUCATION, DISINFORMATION

We also have some of the specifics, for instance survival focus, lack of education, and disinformation.

Many have enough with surviving from day to day. They lack good education. And they are easy prey to disinformation.

That is, of course, part of the strategy for some politicians. They seek to erode K-12 education, keep higher education privatized and costly, do away with social safety nets, and create a citizenry that’s easy pray to disinformation.

Another part of their strategy is the “culture war” which is meant to distract from the far more important and fundamental issue of wealth inequality.

NEO-LIBERAL POLICIES

In the background are the neo-liberal policies implemented worldwide for some decades now, aimed at increasing the wealth of the already extremely wealthy at the cost of everyone else.

That creates dissatisfaction and large segments of the population that are easy prey to politicians who promote simple and misguided solutions, scapegoating, bigotry, and so on. We saw this in the UK with Brexit, and we are seeing it in the US now with Trump.

Although the neo-liberal ideology is relatively new, the dynamic of increasing wealth inequality and people falling for misguided solutions is not new.

THE ONES WHO VOTED FOR HIM DON’T AGREE WITH EVERYTHING

Although some voters may want the complete dystopian world Trump says he wants to create, many don’t.

They may vote for him because he is the supposedly “conservative” candidate, or they are in a squeeze with expenses going up faster than their wages and hope for a change (and don’t realize that they are experiencing a global problem that has little to nothing to do with Biden), or something else. They don’t know, or don’t want to know, all that Trump plans to do, or they think it’s political theater, or they naively think he won’t do it.

Trump won the majority of the votes, and that doesn’t mean that a majority of the population in the US agrees with, or even knows about, everything he wants to do.

WINNER-TAKES-ALL SYSTEM

The US has a winner-takes-all system which leads to a two-party system and polarization.

What we are seeing today is a consequence of this system combined with a fragmentation of the media and news landscape, massive disinformation campaigns, for-profit media that seek sensations and hype, and a significant portion of people receving their info from social media.

TRAUMA BEHAVIOR

What I see in Trump is trauma behavior. Hurt people hurt people. He responds to his own pain, wounds, and trauma with anger, denial, attacks, scapegoating, blame, victimhood, lies, and so on.

I also see trauma behavior among many who follow him.

Some feel they are allowed to deal with (distract themselves from) their own pain through xenophobia, misogyny, racism, and so on. They take his scapegoating as permission for them to act that way too, and it can feel like a relief. (Although it comes with a high cost, including that they don’t find healing for their own pain.)

Some are traumatized by authoritarian figures in their life, and deal with it by justifying it, joining in, and supporting an authoritarian politician. It’s familiar, feels safe, and allows for it all to continue.

Some have given up on mainstream politicians, and deal with their pain and disappointment by supporting someone who will disrupt the system. (Without too much thought of what will come.)

This is collective and intergenerational trauma. It’s the trauma of empire, of domination culture.

This trauma is created by the domination culture, and it perpetuates the domination culture. Collective and intergenerational trauma is part of how the domination culture perpetuates itself.

DOMINATION VS PARTNERSHIP CULTURES

The Trump phenomenon comes out of a culture of domination and power-over.

The origins of this, or at least the strong form, likely came with the agricultural revolution.

Before the agricultural revolution, we were all Indigenous. We lived in smallish groups, we were all more or less equal (apart from in abilities, knowledge, and so on), nobody owned much, we saw ourselves nature, we saw the sacred in everyone and everything, we had an intimate knowledge of the ecosystems we lived within, and so on.

With agriculture, some gained land, wealth, and animals, and others did not. At some point, the ones who had wealth felt a need to justify the wealth inequality, everyone likely felt the need to justify domination over land, plants, and non-human beings, and the ones who dominated other humans felt a need to justify that. They came up with a series of imaginations, and other people eventually bought into these imaginations. It became part of the culture and what new generations learned from early on in life. It became the water we swam in.

Some of these imaginations are: We are separate from nature. Nature is here for our use. We are inherently better than non-human beings and nature. We have a soul, other beings do not. The sacred is not here but somewhere else – in the sky, in a sky god, in the afterlife. You’ll get your reward in the afterlife so don’t bother changing the social order. If you are at the low end of the wealthy spectrum, it’s your fault – it’s because of karma, or laziness, or something else. Pretend to believe what someone tells you and you can’t test out for yourself, and you’ll be saved.

Nature is infinite, has infinite resources for us to use, and infinite capacity to deal with our waste. It’s fine to develop and use an economic system and other systems that assume infinite nature. We can do research on non-human animals because they are so similar to us, and we can mistreat them because they are so different from us. We can imprison and kill non-human animals for our use since they are unable to resist it, and we are more important than them.

We understand best by taking things apart to the smallest parts. A thought can capture a full, final, and absolute truth. If one thought is true, other perspectives are not. (Either-or thinking.) One end of most imagined polarities is good, desirable, and valuable, and the other end is bad, undesirable, or worth less. (Woman and men, adults and children, Europeans and non-Europeans, Christians and non-Christians, light and dark, heaven and hell, and so on.)

These are patently absurd ideas, and yet most people bought into it so it all seemed self-evident, how it is, and something we don’t question. The few who has questioned it have typically been ridiculed, shunned, ignored, or persecuted.

Western culture, and most agricultural societies, are over on the domination side of the domination-partnership spectrum. The US is quite strongly over on that side, not the least because they are an empire. Empires need to be far over on the domination side to survive. Trump is just an expression of this.

INGREDIENTS

The Trump presidency and what comes with it are part of life, they are part of the life that the ones of us alive now are living.

They are among the many ingredients in our life that we are here to make a meal out of.

What kind of meal would I like to make with these ingredients? How is it to look at it all as ingredients for a meal? How can I make it nourishing for myself?

A MIRROR

The world is my mirror. Whatever I see in the world is something I can find in myself.

I can take any story I have about Trump, his supporters, what will happen, and so on, turn it to myself, and find genuine and specific examples of how it’s true. It seems that even, or especially, in the moment I have the thought about someone else, it’s also true about me.

Even if my personality doesn’t like Trump or his policies, and what will happen during his presidency, it’s also a path to my own wholeness.

If I make use of him, and the world in general, as a mirror, it all becomes a way for me to consciously find and embrace more of the richness of who I am.

TONGLEN

Whenever I notice a dislike for someone or something, or distress in myself about something, it’s a reminder that I am caught up in something. I am out of alignment with reality.

I can just notice and relate to it a little more consicously, with perhaps some curiosity to see what comes up. I can take it to more structured inquiry. And one of my favorite explorations is tonglen.

I visualize the other (or myself) in front of me, with their suffering as black smoke. On the in-breath, I inhale that black smoke. And on the out-breath, I visualize breathing light into the person and the light fills them.

I can do this with someone my personality doesn’t like, like, myself, a part of me that’s suffering, and with individuals or groups or even humanity or Earth as a whole. (I sometimes also do it with all the living worlds I imagine throughout the universe.)

Often, I start with someone else, then include myself, and then include larger groups and the Earth as a whole.

Sometimes, I do just one or a few breaths as I go about daily life, and other times I set aside more time for it, especially before falling asleep or after waking up.

This is a powerful and transforming practice, and as I keep doing it and returning to it, it shifts how I relate to the world in general.

In this way, Trump and his followers becomes a reminder for me to do tonglen and allow that exploration to work on me.

LIFE GOES ON & LIVING WHAT I WOULD LIKE TO SEE MORE OF

No matter what, life goes on. This is just another of the many flavors of life.

I allow whatever emotions and reactions come up in me around Trump and what he does. It’s natural and healthy to feel a range of emotions in this situation. I notice these emotions are already allowed and noticed, and also notice whatever reactions come up in me in response to them, and that they too are allowed and noticed – long before any of it is conscious and before there is any intention here. I also remind myself that whatever reactions come up in me is the Earth and existence temporarily and locally responding that way.

I still get up in the morning, go about my day, and go to sleep in the evening.

My tasks are the same, including exploring projections, examining stressful thoughts, and living what I would like to see more of in the world.

In my case and these days, my projects include… Taking care of my health. (I have a chronic illness.) Befriending my experience. Being a good partner, as much as I can. Continuing with the regeneration, reforestation, and food forest project in the Andes.

For me, the main issue in the world today is our global ecological overshoot, and everything else ties into that. The regeneration project is a very small part of the solution, and it feels good to be part of that solution.

NOTICINGS & PERSPECTIVES AS MEDICINE

These are all medicine, or they can be depending on how I make use of them.

Noticing that all is happening within and as the clear awakeness I more fundamentally am is medicine to taking myself as something within content of experience. It reminds me of the more real context of it all as it appears to me.

Reminding myself of the systemic reasons for Trump – domination culture, neoliberalism, disinformation, trauma and so on – helps me see that none of what’s happening is really personal. It’s played out in people’s lives, of course, but the dynamics are much larger than any one of us. It’s medicine for taking it all as having mostly to do with individuals.

Seeing it all as ingredients helps me see that I can create a metaphorical meal out of it all, and seek to make it nourishing for me. It’s medicine for feeling it’s all happening to me and taking a more passive stance.

I can use it as a reminder for tonglen and other explorations. In that way, what’s happening is immensely valuable. It’s medicine for seeing it as (only or mainly) terrible.

Living my life and living some of the more life-centered alternatives is medicine for hopelessness.

Read More

A few pre- and post-election memes

I thought I would share and comment on a few pre- and post-election quotes and memes that came through my social media feed.

Yes, I have always thought it’s absurd and nonsensical and aimed at hijacking people’s emotions to distract them from the real and more fundamental issues. In this context, the far more important issue is the systemic funneling of wealth to the already super-wealthy and away from the middle and working classes.

The neo-liberal ideologies of the last several decades, popularized by people like Reagan and Thatcher, are far more to blame for the problems of most people than unisex bathrooms, transgender people, or even immigrants.

Of course, that’s a pattern in history. People think the bad things will happen to others and not to them. In this case, many Latinos, women, and other groups Trump publicly disparages assume bad things will happen to other Latinos, other women, and so on, and not to them. Don’t be too certain.

Even if it was accurate, is that how you want to live your life? Supporting policies born from xenophobia, misogyny, racism, and scapegoating?

Many if not most of the people voting for Trump will not benefit from his policies and will be hurt by it. For instance, Trump plans to massively cut taxes for the super-wealthy. How is he going to balance that budget? Either by cutting services to ordinary people or by raising taxes for ordinary people. It’s just another example of the right-wing “austerity” policies that benefits the already wealthy and hurts everyone else.

This reflects the weird anti-expert and anti-“elite” sentiments among some people. If your car breaks down, would you go to a random person on the street to get it repaired? If you need surgery, would you go to someone shouting in a bar? If you need to engineer a bridge, would you go to a gardener for advice? No, you would go to someone who is qualified in the area, has gone through extensive training, and knows what they are doing.

This is an example of the classic fallacy of right-wing scapegoating of marginalized groups. Immigrants are not the problem. (Unless you count yourself and your ancestors who actually were and are a real problem to the people who already lived in North America.) They are overwhelmingly, law-abiding, they work for less than others would find acceptable, they pay taxes, and they take jobs others don’t want. They don’t want to rock the boat because they have everything to lose.

Yes, if we look at history, we see that the undoing of democracies often happens through people and parties voted into power through a democratic election. People vote for dictators, either because they don’t think they will actually do what they say they will do, or because they think the bad things will happen to others.

This is an example of the absurdity of the “culture war”. Gay marriage is just two ordinary people who, hopefully, love each other deciding to spend their life together. That’s all. If you happen to not like gay marriage, for whatever weird reason, you are free to not get one for yourself, that’s all.

This is from before the election. Why would you think that someone who is clearly in it only for himself, and perhaps his millionaire and billionaire buddies, would do anything for you? Someone who has a long series of bankruptcies behind him? Someone who is a convicted felon?

Yes, hate is a distraction from our own pain. It’s scapegoating. It’s not taking responsibility for what we are doing to ourselves.

If we rely on scapegoating to distract ourselves from our pain and take that crutch away, we have to face our pain.

Yes, real and responsible therapy will always look at the social systems we live in, how they impact us as individuals, and what we can do about it.

This is very important. That’s why I am making it a practice to rephrase how I think and talk about it for myself. When I feel overwhelmed, I make myself feel overwhelmed. If I feel anger, it’s because I make myself angry. And so on.

That’s a more accurate language, and it reminds me of what’s actually going on.

It aligns my conscious view more with reality.

Woke means kindness, inclusivity, and human rights. The disparaging use of “woke” comes from the right wing in an attempt at discrediting it. Weirdly, it has been adopted by some progressives.

This is why I share, whether it’s here, on social media, or in person when it makes sense.

I don’t do it to convince anyone about anything since that’s very unlikely to happen. I want people who have the views authentic to them.

I do it to show others that they are not alone and it’s OK to speak up.

This is true for any fundamentalist version of any religion. They teach hierarchy, dominance, and that others are wrong. They use fear and intimidation to keep people in line. That’s what we see in Trump and MAGA as well.

Something similar is true for Christianity in general, apart from perhaps some of the more liberal versions. Christianity is fundamentally a post-truth religion in that it asks people to (pretend to) believe in third-hand info they cannot check out for themselves. The Christian church teaches people that others are wrong, or at least not as right as they are. It all too often teaches not to question authority and not to ask difficult questions.

Christianity has often emphasized and exemplified the exact opposite of what Jesus lived and spoke about.

I have always found this ironic. White supremacists in the US, and the ones who scapegoat immigrants in general, seem to forget that they are immigrants too.

They are descendants of illegal and unwelcome immigrants. Immigrants who committed far worse atrocities – genocide, theft, lies, rape – than the current immigrants who are overwhelmingly peaceful, law-abiding, and hard-working.

It seems like a clear case of the pot calling the kettle black when the kettle isn’t even black. It’s a clear case of projection.

It’s often difficult to differentiate between intentional ignorance and just plain ignorance. Often, it’s a mix. People don’t want to know so they don’t set out to know.

People in the US who scapegoat immigrants know they too are immigrants. They are descendants of immigrants, and they are descendants of immigrants who actually did what they accuse current immigrants of doing.

People who support Trump know, or could easily know, what he wants to do, that he will very likely do it, and what the consequences are for themselves and especially for marginalized groups.

I didn’t do K-12 education in the US, which is probably a blessing. Instead, I had a very good education in Norway with highly educated teachers, many of whom were critical thinkers and taught critical thinking to the students. What I know about US history is from there and what I have picked up from books like A People’s History of the US by Howard Zinn.

If it’s true that schools in the US do not teach its full, and pretty grim, history, and the grim history of the world, then there is no wonder why people vote for someone like Trump.

If they knew the history of fascism, it’s difficult to imagine many would support or vote for Trump. Very little good has ever come from fascism, for anyone, including the ones who see themselves as privileged and insulated from the horrors of it. Even for the leaders, very little good has ever come from fascism.

If they knew the ugly history of scapegoating, it’s unlikely that many would vote for Trump. They would see through his cheap tactics of scapegoating to blame vulnerable minorities for systemic problems.

If they knew about the history of tariffs, it’s similarly difficult to understand why someone would vote for Trump. If he imposes the tariffs he promises, which he likely will do, the cost is passed on to the consumers, to the ones voting for him.

Also, if they had taken five minutes to learn about his tax plans and his plans to dismantle social safety nets (including the Affordable Care Act / Obamacare), not many would have voted for him. Why would they vote for someone who will cut taxes for the super-wealthy and increase it for the rest? Why would they vote for someone who will remove the few social safety nets they or someone they love depend on?

It takes just a few minutes to learn about this, although if they never learned the importance of gathering information before making important decisions, that may be why they didn’t do it.

Also very true. The apocalypse is already lived by many beings. It’s lived by the billions of non-human beings imprisoned and living in horrible suffering so we can make clothes out of them, eat them, or do something else to them for our own benefit. It’s lived by the billions living in poverty, hunger, and with treatable illnesses. It’s lived by those severely impacted by our ecological crisis, which is often the already poor. It’s lived by the ecosystems unraveling because of human activity.

This is likely not from Ram Dass but it’s certainly a good pointer.

Read More

The paradox of tolerance – in society and in ourselves

We are seeing the paradox of tolerance play itself out in the US now.

TOLERANCE OF INTOLERANCE IN THE US

The US society has allowed open xenophobia, racism, misogyny, and general bigotry. They have allowed systematic scapegoating, disinformation, and lies. They have allowed open authoritarianism and fascist tendencies. They have allowed all of this in Trump and his followers. They have done very little to stop it.

The media has given Trump the spotlight. The courts have allowed him to get away with just about everything. The law either allows it or is not implemented.

They have allowed all of this to happen for years, to the point where he now will be president again, this time with more experience, a clear plan (Project 2025), and people ready to take crucial positions.

The US tolerance of intolerance has allowed someone who admires Hitler to become president. It has set the stage for authoritarianism to erode and destroy tolerance if Trump gets his way.

If applied too broadly, tolerance destroys itself, as Karl Popper pointed out decades ago.

TOLERANCE OF INTOLERANCE IN OURSELVES

This also applies to my inner society, to how we relate to the different parts of myself.

If I indulge in the different parts of me, it harms my life and my psyche. I am at the whim of any and all parts of me that happen to be activated.

It’s better to relate to the different parts of me with some discernment and avoid indulging in them if they can harm me or my life.

For instance, a part of me tells me something clearly not true. I recognize it’s not true. I know where it comes from. (E.g. childhood experiences, family patterns.) I tell myself what’s genuinely as or more true.

A part of me is deeply sad and has stories to go with it. I allow the sadness and stories. I notice the stories are not true, where they come from, and what’s more true for me. I notice that this is a part of me and far from all of what I am. I notice it’s happening within and as the consciousness I am.

A part of me is strongly reactive. I recognize the signs. I step back. I remove myself from the triggering situation, if possible. I may tell someone what’s going on, to have a witness besides myself. (Helps with accountability.) I allow it to relax and subside. If appropriate, I can then act from a more calm place.

A part of me wants to blame someone or make them into a baddie or a scapegoat. I notice the signs. I notice the fear in me behind it. I take a breath. I find how I am responsible in the situation, if I am directly involved. I find in myself what I see in the other. What story do I have about the person? What do I find when I turn that story to myself? Can I find genuine and specific examples of how I do the same? Maybe even in this situation?

Of course, it’s not always that easy, but it’s a helpful guideline, intention, and ongoing exploration.

Ideas about the future

After Trump was elected last week, I have seen people discussing how this fits into a larger trend and says something about the future.

Some think we are headed into an age of sustainability, inclusivity, and progressive values, and Trump is part of the backlash from a dying and losing mindset.

Some think Trump is a sign of the erosion and dying of democracies, and that the age of democracies was a brief blip in history.

Some think we’ll continue much as before with the usual cycles between right and left.

Some see it as part of a divergence in the US and the world, with some states and countries moving in a progressive direction and some in a more authoritarian and regressive direction. That’s how the world has been for a long time, and it may be even more so with the internet’s echo chambers.

It’s interesting and perhaps even helpful to explore and be aware of these different scenarios. And that’s what they are. They are imaginations about the future, nothing else. They may be more or less rooted in studies, analysis, historical patterns, and so on, and they are still imaginations.

They are not the future. We can’t know anything for certain about the future.

We may invest energy into one of these scenarios and fuel our hopes or fears that way, and that’s a way to find an illusion of safety. We tell ourselves we know how it’s going to be, and that may seem more comfortable than acknowledging that we cannot know.

In my experience, it’s far more comfortable to (a) recognize these scenarios as imaginations, (b) acknowledge that I cannot know, and (c) stay receptive and curious.

What I know is that I can imagine the world I want to live in and live that in my own life.

I am doing it in my own very small way with the food forest and the regeneration and reforestation project, building with local materials and traditional methods, exploring and living from more life-centered worldviews, and so on. And there is always further to go.

It’s always about what I can do and what I am living here and now.

The photo is from our garden.

Trump’s victory: the empire strikes back

Trump won the US election yesterday.

To me, it’s an example of the empire striking back.

People who have internalized the mindset of domination and power-over voted for him and want that culture strengthened, even if it doesn’t seem to be in their interest.

A CULTURE OF DOMINATION

They seem to want a culture of domination and all that comes with it: A zero-sum mindset. Xenophobia, misogyny, racism, and bigotry. Continued destruction of nature. Continued marginalization of the already marginalized.

Why? Because they identify with the values of empire, with the mindset of separation, domination, and power-over.

They know what they are doing. They know what he wants to do. He has said it very clearly. They know he wants to consolidate power, be a dictator from day one, replace civil servants with loyalists, persecute his political opponents, use the military against his own citizens, and in general undermine and attack democratic institutions and principles.

They know he adores Hitler and read Hitler’s speeches to his ex-wife as bedtime stories. They know that the ones who worked most closely with him, including conservative generals, say he ticks all the boxes of fascism. (If they don’t, it’s because of willful ignorance since the info is easily available.)

They may not agree with everything he says or does, or with everything in Project 2025, but they are certainly OK with it. Otherwise, they wouldn’t have voted for him.

THE AGRICULTURAL REVOLUTION

It’s easy to think that this domination mindset has always been here. It’s just part of human life.

In reality, it very likely came with the agricultural revolution.

Before, we were all indigenous. We lived in more egalitarian groups, although obviously with leaders and the higher status of elders with wisdom and practical experience. We saw ourselves as part of the web of life. We saw the sacred in everyone and everything.

With agriculture came the accumulation of wealth, domestication of land, plants, and animals, and social and economic inequality.

How could the wealthy justify this new social order? Why was it OK for them to accumulate while others went without?

To justify this, they created the mindset of empire: We are separate from nature. Nature is here for our use. Nature is infinite. We are better and more important than the rest of what’s living. The sacred is out there in the sky and in a sky god. There is a social hierarchy which is good and divinely prescribed. You will reap your reward in the afterlife. (So don’t bother trying to change anything now.) If you don’t behave, you’ll go to hell. It’s good and honorable to respect those higher up in the hierarchy and uphold the hierarchy itself. If you (pretend to) believe something weird others tell you, and you can’t check out for yourself, you’ll be saved. Thoughts can tell us a final, full, and absolute truth. If one thought is true, alternative ones are wrong. In most polarities, one end is good and the other is less good, bad, or evil. (Men vs women, mind vs body, humans vs non-humans, humans vs nature, our religion vs other religions, European vs non-European, civilization vs savagery, good and bad emotions, and so on.)

Don’t question or challenge any of this, or live alternatives. If you do, you will go to hell, you’ll be ignored, ostracised, ridiculed, marginalized, put in prison, or something else unpleasant.

I imagine that this mindset seemed strange at first and an underhanded way to justify social inequality. It likely came gradually and stepwise, and the specifics have changed over time, although the essence is to justify domination and a few living in luxury while others lived in poverty.

Over time, this mindset became the new normal. New generations grew up with it, internalized it, and most didn’t question it or realize that other worldviews are possible.

TRUMP AND THE MINDSET OF EMPIRE

It was so successful that we now have Trump, and half of the US population wants him to run their country.

The irony is that the alternative, Harris and the Democrats, is also an expression of empire, it’s just a gentler and more compassionate expression of empire. It’s empire with softer edges. (Unless you look at their support for Israel’s decades-long violation of human rights and year-long genocide in Gaza. They seem happy to do their domination abroad.)

It seems that was not enough for many people. They want the more extreme version of it. They want to live in a culture of even stronger domination and marginalization.

DOMINATION AND TRAUMA

Trauma is an important part of this.

A culture and family that operates largely on domination is traumatizing for its citizens and children, and this collective trauma is passed on through the generations.

Hurt people hurt people. If we are hurt, a common way to respond to that hurt is to continue to hurt ourselves and to also hurt others. That’s one way the domination culture continues.

Trump’s behavior is trauma behavior. Bigotry, anger, defensiveness, scapegoating, lies, and so on are all classic, and somewhat extreme, examples of trauma behavior. It’s one of the ways we deal with our own hurt and pain.

I suspect the same is the case for many of those who support and vote for him. Much of that too looks like trauma behavior.

WHAT WILL HAPPEN?

Of course, we don’t know what will happen in the next four years.

We don’t know if or to what degree the US democratic institutions will be able to resist and stay intact.

We don’t know what the consequences will be for what little nature is left.

We don’t know how much suffering women and minorities will have to endure.

We don’t know to what extent far-right bigots around the world will be emboldened by Trump and what they see in the US.

We don’t know how far his MAGA followers in the US will take it in terms of intimidation and even violence against minorities and political opponents.

We don’t know what wars Trump may start, possibly in an attempt to distract from unpopular policies and unite the US population behind him. He avoided wars during the first presidency, but Trump 2.0 will be different.

We also know very well what he wants to do, and some of the things he can do relatively quickly and easily. He clearly wants to deepen our already massive global ecological crisis and hasten a possible end to civilization. (That’s not hyperbole. It’s inevitable with his policies. We are already using far more natural resources than planet Earth can replenish.)

Whatever he does – with the support of Congress and the Supreme Court – can and likely will take decades to correct.

PEOPLE VOTING AGAINST THEIR INTERESTS

To me, there are many ironies in this situation.

One is the many people who seem to vote against their own interests. Why do they vote for someone who has promised to make their lives worse?

For instance, why do Latinos and Hispanics vote for someone who is publicly racist, bigoted, and has nothing but disdain for them? One answer is that they are conservative because of Catholicism, and they mistakenly see him as conservative. Some may want to join the ranks of the oppressor since it seems safer, and they think that voting for Trump and joining the Republicans will do that. Some may assume that when he disparages Latinos, he means the others, not them. Some may think that when he talks about deporting immigrants, he doesn’t mean it (he does) or it will impact others and not them (how do you know?).

Why do some Christians support him? He is clearly not a Christian. In his life, he is the polar opposite of the example set by Jesus in the New Testament. His policies of cruelty are the most un-Christian imaginable. The answer is likely that some brands of conservative Christianity, especially in the US, represent a very distorted form of Christianity, one that’s far from the original principles laid out by Jesus.

Why do women vote for someone who is a misogynist and rapist and wants to allow states to ban abortion? (Likely because they buy into patriarchy, other things matter more, or they think abortion is something others will need and not them.)

Why do minorities and vulnerable groups vote for Trump when they know his presidency will embolden bigots worldwide? Why do women support Trump when they know his presidency will cause an upsurge in misogyny and misogynist behavior that may even impact them directly? Why do ethnic minorities, like Latinos, vote for a racist who will invite openly racist behavior among many, when they may be the target of it? (A large percentage of Latinos voted for Trump, while few Blacks did – likely because they know what may and will happen based on their history.)

Why do workers vote for someone who wants to do away with unions? (Likely because they think he is anti-elite, while he really is in it for himself and his rich buddies.)

Why do working and middle-class people vote for someone who wants to cut taxes for the super-rich and increase taxes for everyone else? Why do they vote for someone who wants to impose tarrifs when it’s the ordinary people that will have to pay for it? (Likely because they are unaware of it, or other things matter more for them.)

Why do people who depend on the Affordable Care Act (ACA, PPACA, ObamaCare) vote for someone who wants to do away with it? (Likely because they don’t realize what will happen and the impact it will have on their lives.)

Why do people who depend on the (already imperfect) social safety net in the US, or who may depend on it in the future, vote for someone who wants to erode and – if he can – remove it? (Do they think this too is about others, not them?)

Why do people who want to shake things up and try something different choose an openly fascist felon, rapist, and con man like Trump? He is very unlikely to give them what they want, and far more likely to give them what they don’t want. From history, we know what authoritarianism and fascism lead to, and he is a textbook authoritarian and fascist.

Why would anyone vote for someone who wants to expand our collective ecological footprint when it’s already larger than this planet? Our planet cannot replenish natural resources at the rate we use them. We are living on a savings account that’s rapidly going down. This is ecocidal and suicidal.

BAD THINGS WILL HAPPEN TO OTHERS, NOT ME

The ones supporting Trump know he wants to do terrible things to several groups in society, including migrants, women, LGBT+ people, and his political critics and opponents.

They must be OK with it.

Why? Perhaps because of dehumanization. They don’t see these people as real people. They don’t see them as deserving to be treated humanely and with respect and understanding.

Equally important, they likely think that bad things will happen to other people, not themselves.

History tells us a different story.

PROTECTED BY PRIVILEGE

The “bad things will happen to others” attitude has another aspect, and that’s privilege.

White people think the bad will happen to non-whites. Christians think the bad things will happen to the non-Christians. Born citizens think bad things will happen (only) to immigrants. Men think the bad things will happen to women. Republicans (including Latinos etc.) think the bad things will happen to non-Republicans.

They all feel protected by privilege. They are protected because they belong to a privileged group.

That’s not how this works.

THOSE WHO GET INTO HIS ORBIT

I am also surprised by those who willingly join his orbit. (Elon Musk is one of them.)

Have they not seen what tends to happen to those who do?

Do they think this too will happen to others and not them?

BLAME & SCAPEGOATING

The first chapter in the authoritarian playbook is blame and scapegoating, which Trump masters.

When things inevitably go haywire during his presidency, he will continue to blame and scapegoate. It’s not his actions and policies that are the problem, it’s all the other people.

Many of his followers will do this as well. When things get worse for them during his presidency – prices go up because of tariffs, they lose social safety nets, public programs they depend on are cut, people they know are deported, they find themselves in a more harsh and unforgiving society – they will overlook that this is the predictable and predicted outcome of Trump’s policies and instead continue to blame the same groups.

THE US HISTORY OF OVERTHROWING DEMOCRACIES

Another irony is that the US has a history of undermining and overthrowing democracies and installing far-right dictatorships. They have done so across the world for decades.

Now, they are installing someone as president who (a) openly admires dictators, (b) explicitly says he wants to create a dictatorship and be a dictator, and (c) has a plan (project 2025) and people in place to do exactly that.

Again, we don’t know exactly what will happen and how it will unfold. There are institutions and people who will resist. But we know that’s what he wants.

THE LARGER TRENDS

It’s always tempting to look at how these events fit into larger trends, although it’s by necessity speculation.

Some think the world is moving in a more progressive direction, focused on sustainability, inclusivity, and so on. Trump and his followers represent a backlash from the dying mindset of empire. I would like that to be true. The history of the West, at least, has been a slow movement of widening circles of inclusivity and who we see as “us”. It’s a projection into the future and it’s easy to see it as wishful thinking.

Some see liberal democracies as a historical aberration. They are a recent innovation, had their peak for a few decades after WW2, and are now on the decline in the world. Maybe we won’t see that many healthy liberal democracies in the future, and Trump and his movement are a part of the overall decline of democracies.

It’s also possible that this election is just part of the usual fluctuations between progressive and regressive tendencies, and it will be a blip in the larger history of a flawed democracy. It won’t be as bad as some think, or as good as his followers assume. (Personally, I think it will be pretty bad and it will take decades to undo and correct.)

If I were to guess, I imagine we’ll see a continued divergence in the US and the world. Some countries, states, and regions will move in a more partnership-oriented direction, and others will move in a more domination-oriented direction.

THE OVERARCHING ISSUE: GLOBAL ECOLOGICAL OVERSHOOT

One thing we know for certain is that we are in a massive global ecological crisis.

We are in a global ecological overshoot where we use far more resources than Earth can generate. That can’t last, and it will get much worse before it gets better if it gets better while we are around.

This is the context for our civilization today and it’s by far the most important issue, although it seems quite far down on the list of priorities for most people. (Understandably so since most people have enough with daily tasks and challenges and surviving.)

Will we find the collective will to make the necessary and thorough changes to all the systems of our civilization? How many will die before this happens? Will we be able to correctly identify the problem? Will we be able to focus on and implement the solutions, many of which we already have?

How will we deal with the consequences of the breakdown of our local, regional, and global ecosystems? The inevitable mass migrations? The loss of infrastructure? The food shortages? The lack of clean drinking water? Not having enough resources to repair and fix all the damage? Will large parts of humanity decent into infighting instead of focusing on the real solutions?

Will we see a world where some regions and countries take this seriously and do most of the heavy lifting, while other parts of the world continue much as before?

If we don’t find the collective will in time, there is only one outcome and that’s the unraveling of our civilization and huge loss of human life. (Along with an even more enormous loss of individuals of other species, and whole species.)

WHAT WILL HAPPEN WITH THE US?

It’s tempting to look at what may happen with the US in the coming decades, although that too is obvisouly speculation.

One thing that may happen is a shift from federal to state control and power. That’s what the Republicans want, and I imagine many in the more liberal states may eventually want it as well to avoid laws and regulations dictated by votes of conservatives in other states.

It will also indirectly reduce the problem with the electoral college which may be difficult to impossible to correct in itself.

In that case, we’ll see largely conservative states move further in a conservative direction, and liberal states move further in a liberal direction. We’ll also likely see more people moving to the states where they feel more at home.

It will also be a large scale experiment. We’ll get to see the effects of the different policies. Of course, the world is already that experiment. It doesn’t seem that countries often look to other countries for good solutions. (If they did, and they looked at what actually works in terms of the well being of the citizens, most would want to adopt a model similar to the Nordic countries.)

Several years ago, I started on a fiction story set a few decades in the future on the US West Coast. It’s set in that type of system where the states and local government decides most things, many states and regions have moved further in a conservative direction, and the West Coast has moved further in a progressive and sustainable direction.

I don’t know how that kind of process would unfold. What I know is that if it happens, it will come with its own drawbacks, many of which it’s difficult for us to foresee.

BE THE CHANGE YOU WANT TO SEE IN THE WORLD

Whether this is the first day of the Apocalypse or the first day of the Golden Age, the work remains the same…to love each other and ease as much suffering as possible.
– often attributed to Ram Dass

No matter what happens, we know what to do. As Joanna Macy says, there are (a) stopping actions to reduce the harm, (b) engaging in developing and living from more life-centered and partnership-oriented worldviews, and (c) developing and living practical solutions.

CONSERVATIVE PARTNERSHIP MINDSET

I know it’s unfair to real conservatives to call Trump a conservative. Other labels would be more fitting, like populist, nationalist, authoritarian, oligarch, fascist, reactionary, demagogue, or isolationist.

It’s also unfair to assume that a progressive orientation is always a partnership orientation, or that conservatism means domination.

There is always elements of both domination and partnership in all movements, cultures, and subcultures. It’s not possible to have just one.

It’s not difficult to find examples of domination elements in progressive politics. Sometimes, they are necessary since we live in that kind of system. Other times, they are excessive, misguided, and alienating.

It’s also easy to imagine conservatism with a partnership mindset. A conservative orientation can very well come with a genuine care of nature and creation, a genuine wish for deep democracy, a genuine desire to take care of those least fortunate in society, and so on.

I love that kind of conservatism. It may not be exactly how I see it in every way, but I love it and feel aligned with it.

WHAT I CAN DO

I lived in the US for about two decades, love the nature and the progressive subculture, and still feel quite connected, also because many of my friends are there. That’s why I still have some emotional investment in what’s happening in the US. Right now, immediately after this election, I make myself sad and angry over what I see happening there.

So what can I do?

I remind myself that about half of the people in the US didn’t want Trump. Many feel the way I feel now.

A lot of good things are happening in the world. Many people worldwide are working for a more inclusive and sustainable society. Many are developing and living the solutions.

In the bigger picture, it’s likely a blip. (Unless something catastrophic happens, but something catastrophic can happen anyway.) In five years, it may well belong to the past and the US is onto something quite different.

I am grateful for my friends and communities who tend to have more of a partnership orientation, and maybe especially the permaculture community these days.

I spend time in nature and work in the food forest. It’s nourishing and feels good.

I did tonglen yesterday – with Trump, his followers, and myself. I will do it again today and plan to continue. It feels good and softens a sense of I and Other.

I keep exploring projections, including Trump in myself. What stories do I have about him and his followers? What do I find when I turn those stories to myself? Can I find specific and genuine examples of doing the same? (Including right now, in how I see them?)

I use the natural stress-releasing processes of the body to release tension and find more resilience. (Tension and Trauma Release Exercises / TRE.)

I notice how the consciousness I am forms itself into my experience of all of it – this human self, Trump, the US, this world.

I remind myself that we are local and temporary expressions of the unfolding dynamics of the universe and this living planet. All f this is existence – the universe, this planet, consciousness – expressing, exploring, and experiencing itself in always new ways.

I will be even more conscious of my news diet. I also read rather than watch, which makes it easier.

I will speak up about and live what I want to see more of in the world.

I keep living my life. My daily life consists of the same as before. Life goes on.

I remind myself that this too will pass. Authoritarian leaders are a natural outcome of the civilization we have (domination mindset), and they come and go.

Read More

Why do some support Trump even if they likely will be hurt by his policies?

Almost against my will, I find myself fascinated by why so many support Trump’s policies (and Project 2025), even if it will very likely hurt them1.

WE ARE NOT ALWAYS RATIONAL

Why do some support Trump and his policies even if it will likely hurt them?

The short answer is likely that these things are not completely, or even mostly, rational. Or it’s rational in a way I am not aware of or wouldn’t call rational.

I tend to investigate, learn, and think through these things, and support and vote for the one(s) who seem to have the best policies for society as a whole, for ecology, and for future generations. So I – unconsciously and viscerally – assume it must be like that for others too, even if I know it’s not always that way. It’s not always that way for me, in other areas of life.

Why did many in Germany in the 1920s and 1930s support Hitler even if they (somewhere in them) must have known that his ideology – based on misinformation, hatred, and division – would lead them into dictatorship and disaster? It was certainly not just for rational reasons, or for reasons that fit my kind of rationality.

A GUESS: IGNORED BY THE POLITICIANS AND THE “ELITE”

Why do some support Trump even if his policies will likely hurt them?

The main reason may be that many feel let down by politicians and the “elite”. They feel overlooked, ignored, and left to fend for themselves. They don’t have good social safety nets. Their income may be below the poverty line even if they work two jobs. They see a few others earning huge amounts of money. They may see their bosses earning tens or hundreds or more times as much as they do, and apparently do less for it. They are aware of the enormous and increasing gap in income and wealth between the few wealthy and the many poor.

They know that mainstream politicians have done little to help them. Neither Democrats nor Republicans have taken this seriously, prioritized it, and done much about it. They know that policies often follow the interests of Big Money and that politicians are in the pockets of corporations and the super-wealthy. (Of course, there are politicians who take this seriously, but it’s limited what they can do because of the system they function within.)

This is nothing new, of course. This inequality and ideologies to justify it came with the agricultural revolution. It’s inherent in our system. The most recent form is the neo-liberalism made popular in the 1980s (Reagan, Thatcher) and continued until now. I have seen statistics saying that the wealth inequality in the US these days is similar to France before the French Revolution, and although there are several ways to calculate these things, I wouldn’t be surprised. They had their revolution, and the US has Trump.

I completely agree and sympathize with the frustration that inevitably comes with this dramatic inequality. At the same time, I don’t understand how Trump can be the solution (if anything, he is this problem on steroids), but I understand the desperation, frustration, anger, and despair that can lead someone to support a candidate who seems different and outside of the mainstream.

This also points to a solution to the Trump and emerging fascism problem in the US: Create good social safety nets. Tax the super-wealthy and use the money for the benefit of everyone. Make higher education tax-sponsored and free to the students. Implement good universal healthcare. (Far less expensive than the current system.) Encourage strong unions. Take the concerns of the working class seriously. Of course, this is easier said than done. Strong forces oppose this, and many ordinary citizens have been brainwashed to reject these solutions.

MORE GUESSES

What are some more specific reasons? Why do some support Trump even if his policies may hurt them?

Some may be guided by misinformation. They assume his economic policies will be good for them, and don’t realize that tariffs are ultimately paid by ordinary people and that the tax cuts go to the already extremely wealthy, not to them (their taxes are likely to go up).

Some may be seduced by his cheap scapegoating of minority groups. Instead of going into a real analysis of the problem, Trump blames immigrants and foreigners for the problems in the US. (A classic leaf out of the fascist playbook.)

Some know that he has a dislike or hatred for their group – women, people of color, immigrants, LGBT+ – but other things take priority for them. They may be loyal to the Republican party. They may be misled to think his economic policies will be good for them. Maybe they think his policies targeting these groups won’t affect them.

Some may assume that much of his rhetoric is political theater. He says a lot of weird things, and he won’t actually do it. They ignore Project 2025 and that he has a system, people, and plan in place to do exactly what he says he will do.

He says he will use the military against US citizens, he will persecute his political enemies, he will be a dictator from day one, he will consolidate power in the presidency, he will undo the normal checks and balances of democracy, he will limit the freedom of the press, he will replace civil servants with loyalists, and so on, and he won’t actually do it, in their mind. (Or maybe they naively assume it won’t matter that much.)

Some may see him as a strong leader or successful businessman and the right person to lead the country and don’t care much about his specific policies. Of course, he is not a strong leader. He is far too volatile, irrational, and egocentric to be a good leader. He is also far too enamored with authoritarian leaders abroad to be able to stand up to them.

He is also clearly not a successful businessman. Would a successful businessman have time or interest in signing on to a TV show? (The Apprentice.) Would a successful businessman have six bankruptcies?

Would a capable businessman have such a huge string of past and current lawsuits against him? Would a good leader have so many people from his previous administration go against him in public, calling him dangerous, unhinged, and fascist?

A few extremely wealthy may benefit from his economic policies, at least in the short term. It comes with a huge cost to the rest of society, and especially several minority groups, and they don’t seem to care enough about that to not support him.

They also don’t seem to care that his policies will very likely be damaging to the US – and US economy – in the long run. He alienates former allies, he loves tarrifs, he doesn’t support research or higher education, he wants to undo the fabric of society that makes the US work as well as it does.

Some may be contrarians. Most media, experts, and well-educated liberal people see Trump as deranged, unhinged, and fascist, so they want to support him just to poke the liberal elite in the eye. They prioritize this over supporting someone who, by all normal criteria, actually is a fascist.

Some may see someone who mirrors their own pain and hatred. He hates women, people of color, LGBT+, immigrants, and so on, and they do too. They are happy that he seems to validate their own hatred and don’t care much about anything else. Some within these groups may have internalized this hatred, even if they are the target. Some may also see themselves as the exception: Yes, I am a woman, person of color, immigrant, LGBT+, but I am not like others in that group.

Said another way, some may resonate with his trauma behavior. Trump is a living ball of trauma behavior. They too have trauma and choose to deal with it through going into anger, bigotry, us vs them thinking, blame, scapegoating, and so on, so they resonate with it in him. He is one of them. They don’t care so much about the rest.

Some may not know enough about history to realize that this is exactly how democracy dies. Trump’s approach fits all the hallmarks of fascism, and the shift into a dictatorship has often looked just like the Trump movement looks now.

Some, about half of us, have a genetic predisposition for conservatism. Some of these may lean towards supporting any conservative candidate independent of specifics.

Some say they want change just of the sake of change. They don’t care so much what kind of change. To me, this seems profoundly misguided.

Some may think that anything is better than what they have now. To me, that’s a clear trauma response. They don’t realize what they have and how much worse it can get. They likely don’t know enough history to understand, or they assume it won’t be that bad or that they won’t be affected.

Some see him as the Great Disruptor that will usher in something new. Yes, he will. At least, he will try, although the changes may not be what you wish to see or experience. His dystopian world may not be as amazing as you think or lead to the changes you wish to see.

Some see their privilege fading, as white Christians in an increasingly more diverse society. They are so attached to being on top of the hierarchy that they cannot bear being just one group of many. This is so important to them that they don’t care if they lose democracy, if large groups of innocent people are made to suffer, if their economy worsens, and so on.

Some may have a zero-sum mindset. They assume, perhaps based on personal painful experience, that if you win, I lose, and for me to win, you must lose. Trump embodies that zero-sum mindset. They overlook that the world is full of examples of win-win solutions where we all benefit. (The social safety net in the Nordic countries is one of many examples.)

WHAT’S RATIONAL TO ME MAY NOT BE RATIONAL TO YOU

I have my own ideas of what’s rational, and these reflect my own background and biases.

To me, it’s rational to find solutions – and support policies – that seem good for society as a whole, for the living systems we are part of, and for future generations. I support democracy since, although it’s a flawed system, it’s the best we have. I seek win-win-win solutions since they are better for all of us. I support inclusivity since a more inclusive society is better for all of us.

What’s rational for someone else may be different. As mentioned above, they may operate on misinformation. They may prioritize one or a few things, and ignore or be OK with the rest that comes with it. For them, that’s rational.

THE WORLD IS MY MIRROR

The world is my mirror, also here.

I can take any one of the stories I have about Trump or his supporters, turn it to myself, and find genuine and specific examples of how it’s true. Most likely, I can even find it in the moment I have these thoughts about them. I do what I see in them, at this moment.

That’s humbling, and it’s also amazing, liberating, and enlivening. It helps me find more of my own richness. It helps me relate to these sides of me with a little more awareness. It helps me see myself in them and erode my imagination of me versus them.

This is an ongoing process. My fascination, which I started with in this article, is a clear sign that there is more for me to explore and discover here. The fascination is a sign that I see something in them I am not so aware of in myself yet.

Also, all of this is happening within and as what I am. The consciousness I am forms itself into all of it.

THE UPSIDE OF TRUMP

What are some upsides of Trump?

He highlights the frustration among many about the growing inequality coming from decades of neo-liberal policies. He highlights how the working class feels left behind.

He highlights the weirdness of the US political system where one candidate wins the popular vote, and the other becomes president. (Because of the arcane, outdated, and essentially meaningless electoral college.)

He mirrors what’s in all of us. He shows us our shadow. (Whether we consciously notice, embrace, and make use of it is another matter.)

A Trump presidency will fuel a lot of effort to create a more life-centered and kind society. Many of us will channel our frustration into this kind of work. (I know it’s that for me.) It will create even more of a sense of urgency.

Who knows what social dynamics will be set in motion from a Trump presidency? In a slightly larger historical picture, it’s a blip, and we may see it as a transition leading into something more life-centered. (The question is if we have time for this now, considering we are in the middle of a global ecological crisis.)

We will still live our daily lives. Life moves on. Whatever he represents and creates will not last. There have been many like him throughout history, and they are soon left in the dust of history after some years or decades.

THE BIGGER PICTURE

There is a bigger picture here too.

The Universe forms itself into this living planet and us, including our politics and social dynamics.

It’s all part of existence expressing, exploring, and experiencing itself in always new ways.

It seems that the exploration is the point, not any particular outcome.

From another angle, we can say that this is Spirit taking all of these forms. It’s Spirit expressing, exploring, and experiencing itself in all of these ways.

It’s the play of existence. And just like a theater play, it’s the experience that’s the point.

NOTES

  1. How may those voting for him be hurt by his policies? What are some examples of how they are voting against their interests?
    (a) Latinos may be deported or have friends or family deported, even if they are legally in the US. Trump will seek to find ways to remove the protection even of many who are in the US legally, so they can be deported. This, of course, goes for all immigrants.
    (b) Trump will find ways to erode the already weak social safety nets in the US. If you benefit from the Affordable Care Act (Obama-care), Medicaid, or similar, you may find you suddenly lost it.
    (c) In general, Trump’s aim is to funnel money to the already super wealthy and away from everyone else. If you are not super wealthy, you will likely find you are in a worse financial situation.
    (d) He is unhinged, and unhinged policies are generally not good for the society or economy.
    (e) Although he seemed war-averse during his first term, that may change. Trump 2.0 will likely be quite different from Trump 1.0.
    (f) If you live in the US, you’ll find that society becomes increasingly more polarized. That’s not good for anyone. (If you are bigoted, you may think so, but it’s not true.)
    (g) If you are a worker, expect your worker rights to be eroded.
    (h) If you have a child in school, or work in the public school system, expect the school system to be further weakened.
    (i) If you like democracy, or the ability to speak up without fear of the consequences, or free press, expect all of that to get worse.
    (j) Expect the US economy and position in the world to worsen over the coming years and decades through the gutting of science and education.
    (k) Expect the US position in the world in general to worsen, through Trump’s bullying and mafia tactics in terms of international relations.
    (l) Don’t expect much of a boost in terms of foreign students and visitors to the US. Most people around the world don’t like facism or countries that elect facist leaders.

These are just a few examples, and none of it is very difficult to predict. It comes naturally from his words, actions, and generally inclinations. It’s also a part of his playbook, Project 2025.

NOTE ON ELECTION DAY

It’s the morning of the election day in the US (November 5, 2024). The ones I follow predict (a) a clear win of the popular vote for Harris which doesn’t matter, and otherwise (b) a very close election that (c) can lead to a landslide in either direction because of the winner-takes-all system in the US, (d) and likely a very messy situation if Harris wins. How that messiness unfolds is anyone’s guess, although it will likely involve many legal cases, a politicized legal system, intimidation, possible violence, and so on.

Trump has, of course, set the stage by repeating that the previous election was stolen and that the only way he can lose this time is if they steal it again. This is another example of his habitual projections. He says that others are doing, or will do, what he is planning to do or are already doing.

I am also reminded that the US has a long history of undermining and overthrowing democracies and installing right-wing governments. Now, they may be doing it to themselves. I guess that’s a kind of karma. They are finally applying their habit to themselves.

UPDATE JULY 2025

It’s now July 5, 2025, and the “big bill” has been approved by congress. This bill is explicitly designed to fullen money to the already extremely wealthy (tax cuts for the rich) and cut programs that benefit everyone else, including the most poor.

There is nothing new here. This is what we knew Trump wanted to do, and what he had everything in place to do, long before the election. This is what Project 2025 is about.

Still, more than half of the voters in the US voted for him and these policies, and these changes that directly hurt most of them.

I haven’t written follow-ups to my 2024 posts about Trump because there isn’t much to say. What’s unfolding is what we knew would unfold, unless a miracle happened.

The ones who voted for him are hurt by his policies. It’s what we knew would happen.

Of course, we see that in many other areas of life. Daily, the vast majority of people vote for “business as usual” – with their lives, priorities, money, and in elections. They want us to go further into global ecological overshoot. They want the collapse of our civilization. That’s what they vote for through how they live.

They can’t say they didn’t know, because this information is widely available. They can’t say they thought someone else would take care of it, because that obviously isn’t happening. They can’t say they thought we had more time, because we are already in the middle of it.

Read More

The erosion and fall of democracy? Trump and Project 2025

From the moment Trump entered the presidential race in 2015, I have said that the most dangerous consequence is the erosion of democracy. That seems even more clear now when he is becoming more openly fascist and has a system, plan, and people ready if he is re-elected next week.

In Germany in the 1920s and 1930s, people largely took democracy for granted. This unhinged guy Hitler won’t actually do what he says he will do, it‘s just political theater. These days, many people in the US say the same about Trump. He is obviously bigoted and unhinged, but he is not actually going to do what he says he’ll do.

To me, that seems naive. He’ll most likely do, or try to do, exactly what he says he will do. He has a plan to follow (project 2025), he has people ready to enter crucial positions, and he is not going to repeat the same “mistake” he made when he first became president, which was to appoint people who didn’t back up his every whim and wish.

The erosion of democracy historically looks exactly like what we are seeing in the US today, and what we have seen over the last many years starting with the Tea Party, which paved the way for Trump and MAGA.

The undoing of democracy historically looks exactly like what we are seeing in the US today, and what we will see unfold if Trump is re-elected. Of course, there are institutions that will oppose it, but Trump has a plan in place to undo that opposition. He wants to consolidate power in the presidency and replace everyone in government, at all levels, who oppose him with loyal followers. That’s his explicit plan and there is no reason to doubt that he will do everything he can to implement it.

It may not happen for any number of reasons, but it’s important to take the situation as seriously as it deserves. Without a functioning democracy, it’s difficult to get anything done with the many changes the world asks of us today.

NY TIMES ARTICLE

I thought I would update with a New York Times article: Once Top Advisers to Trump, They Now Call Him ‘Liar,’ ‘Fascist’ and ‘Unfit’

If it wasn’t abundantly clear before, it’s even more so now. Nobody can say they didn’t know. The information has been available for years.

More info below.

Read More

Nobody sees themselves as the villain

Nobody sees themselves as a villain.

That’s a common observation, and it seems largely true.

THE WAYS IT’S TRUE

People who support fascism don’t see themselves as a villain. They see themselves as good people and good citizens. They see it as supporting and upholding tradition and what’s good about their country. They turn a blind eye to the horrors they know come with it because they think it won’t impact them.

In general, when we react to our trauma in ways that hurt others and ourselves, we also don’t see ourselves as a villain. We know we act on our own hurt. We know our own history and what led to it. We may distract ourselves from what we know – that we hurt others and ourselves because of our own hurt – through engaging in stories that apparently justify and rationalize it.

NOT COMPLETELY TRUE

Of course, it’s also not entirely true.

People who support fascism know the horrors that come with it. They know they support it, or at least are OK with it. They know how that looks, and that it fits the image of a villain.

When we act on our reaction to trauma and hurt others and ourselves, we know what we are doing. In spite of whatever we may tell ourselves about it, we know what’s happening. We know we fit the image of someone hurting others and ourselves, and we likely don’t like it. That may lead us to fuel the behavior and justifications, or it can make us pause and take a closer look.

We can also fully embrace the villain identity in two very different ways. We can embrace it in the sense of consciously identifying with it and living from and as it. (Happens in some cases of strong trauma.) We can also embrace it as one of many parts of us, and relate to it with more awareness and kindness. (Happens when we have a more healthy and mature orientation.)

MORE WAYS TO DISTRACT OURSELVES

There are often more dynamics going on here, including projections.

If we fit the image of a villain and know it and don’t want to see it, we may put it on others. We make others into the villain. That way, we can distract ourselves from seeing it in ourselves.

Someone is a villain – someone is a bad person doing bad things – and it’s that guy, not me.

More generally, everything I see in the world is also here in me. I can take any story I have about anyone or anything, turn it around to myself, and find specific and genuine examples of how it’s true. I can find it in myself.

THE UNITED STATES TODAY

We are one week from the US presidential election, which is why I am revisiting this familiar topic.

It’s playing itself out in one of the largest and most influential countries in the world.

People who see themselves as good people support and vote for a fascist. They support someone who is fascinated by and admires Hitler. Someone who read Hitler’s speeches to his former wife as bedtime stories. Someone who, among many other things, wants to persecute and prosecute his political enemies just because they oppose his policies. Someone who wants to use the military against people of his own country. Someone who wants to centralize power and do away with the basics of democracy.

Someone who has as a motto: Attack attack attack. Admit nothing, deny everything. Always claim victory.

Someone who is unashamedly sexist, racist, and bigoted and is using the old and tired (and unfortunately successful) strategy of scapegoating the already least fortunate in society.

They see it as upholding and protecting what’s good about their country. They turn a blind eye to the horrors that come with it. They do it because they think nothing bad will happen to them, only to others.

Fascism in the US

The Trump movement is a fascist movement. It fits most if not all of the hallmarks of historical fascism.

Even his former chief of staff, John Kelly, who knows him better than most, says he is a fascist, someone fascinated by, admiring of, and wanting to emulate Hitler.

Some say that Trump is the Great Disruptor, the one who will shake things up. If you are unhappy with some of the systemic problems in the world today, he offers an opportunity to change all that.

Compare that with reality: He scapegoats the weakest groups in society (immigrants), wants to cut taxes for the super-wealthy and put the burden on the rest, plans to persecute his political opponents, will increase the power of the president, wants to replace civil servants with loyalists, is itching to use the military against protesters, and so on. (See, for instance, If Trump Wins from the New York Times.)

To me, it seems incredibly naive to see him as someone who will bring about any kind of desired change. You would have to know very little about history to assume that.

We know what he wants to do, and few of us would enjoy living in the dystopian world he wants to create.

Yes, we need a profound transformation of our civilization. No, it will not happen because of Trump.

If anything, the mindset of Trump and his supporters is an example of what needs to go. They represent the mindset of colonialism, patriarchy, strict social hierarchies, sexism, racism, and so on. The white supremacist in him and the ones who support him is scared of the changes happening in the US now. They are scared of being in the minority, and they assume they will be treated as they historically have treated minorities. That seems to be the essence of the Trump movement and the Trump Republicans.

Of course, people support him for a range of reasons. Some are cynical and think they may personally benefit from his policies. Some want a strong leader, or at least someone who fits their distorted image of what strength is. Some want to find scapegoats. Some want to ban abortion and don’t care about the rest of him and his policies. I would assume many don’t know much about history. (Republicans generally try to reduce the quality of the educational system in the US, partly or mainly because they know that uneducated people are more likely to be seduced by their rhetoric.) Some want to disrupt the system and see him as the person to do that, without considering history and the likely outcome of his particular brand of disruption.

It’s unfortunately unsurprising that we see the rise of fascism in the US now. They never had real fascism on their soil, and the generations that saw how it unfolded in Europe and the horrors it brought are mostly gone now. Also, both parties in the US have largely failed the working class so they are turning to something different in desperation.

I see much of the support behind Trump as a trauma reaction. For many, it may come out of financial insecurity, lack of good social safety nets, and feeling let down by the “elite” – regular politicians and policymakers. I completely agree. Politicians in the US, whether Democrats or Republicans, are largely in the pocket of Big Money, and the policies are often aimed at lining the pockets of those who already have much at the expense of everyone else. Although Trump sells himself as something different, he is more of the same only to an even more extreme degree.

Some may feel let down by mainstream politicians in other ways, see Trump as the Great Disruptor, and hope something desirable will come out of his chaos. That too seems like a trauma reaction to me. It looks like someone hurt, and acting in extreme ways to deal with – and distract themselves from – that hurt.

Harris and the Democrats don’t have the real solutions to the challenges that face us today. They don’t want to deal with the profound systemic changes required for us to transition into a more ecologically sound civilization (a less ecocidal and suicidal one). But they are a step in that direction compared with Trump and the Republicans.

If Harris wins, it will not be the end of Trump and his supporters. They will do whatever they can to disrupt. Some of them even want some kind of civil war and may start waging it on their own, in whatever form that takes. Most likely violence against election officials, minorities, and political opponents.

There is another side to this, and that is finding all this in myself. How am I like Trump and his supporters? What stories do I have about them? What do I find when I turn these stories to myself? Can I find genuine and specific examples of how it’s true?

What happens when I do tonglen with Trump and his supporters, and with myself distressed by it?

Also, all of it is happening within and as the consciousness I am. To me, the consciousness I am forms itself into all of it.

Also, this living system we call Earth has formed itself into all of it – our civilization, Democrats, Republicans, and so on. These dynamics all happen within and as this living system. It’s a temporary and local expression of the dynamics of this living system. This doesn’t change what we need to do to try to steer society in a better direction, but it does provide a different context for understanding it.

UPDATE OCTOBER 29, 2024

It’s now a few days later, and I thought I would add this video that outlines reasons from a purely legal perspective to keep Trump out of office. This election is, as many point out, an election between maintaining or eroding the democracy in the US. (Which is, of course, already flawed and eroded.) It’s a simple choice.

I also see that Trump said, “I am not a Nazi“. This is a rare true statement from him. Nobody said he was a Nazi. He is not a member of the National Socialist German Workers’ Party (NSDAP) in Germany in the 1920s-1945. He fits the characteristics of a fascist, which is a broader and more general term.

It’s tempting to make excuses for the people supporting Trump: They are bamboozled by his lies. They have watched too much Fox News. They don’t believe he will do what he says he will do. They think someone will stop him from engaging in the worst atrocities. They assume fascism and the end of democracy can’t happen in the US. They don’t realize that his words and actions fit closely the definition of fascist. They don’t know enough history to know what happens in countries that elect leaders that bring them into fascism. They are good people who support just a few of his policies. They are traumatized and choose a leader who feeds into their trauma

That may all be true, and those are also no excuses. If they wanted to know, they would know.

Also, they very likely know several things, even if they get their info from Fox News: They know how he scapegoats the already marginalized. They know that his policies will amplify the suffering of groups that already suffer immensely. They know he wants to remove fundamental rights from women. They know he will cut the taxes of the already super-wealthy at the cost of everyone else. They know he wants to erode democracy in innumerable ways. They know he wants to persecute his political opponents. They know he wants to use the military against US citizens. They know he mocks those in the military. They know that many of those who worked with him when he was president have distanced themselves from him and say he is dangerous, unhinged, and even a fascist.

The people who support him and vote for him support those policies or are OK with it, and that says a lot about them.

I’ll include this too about Trump’s fascist language, sometimes lifted directly from Mussolini and others.

Read More

Do you see me as a human?

One of the strategies of Trump, and fascists in general, is to use dehumanizing language. He thrives on creating out-groups and dehumanizing them so they can be scapegoats. He also uses dehumanizing language to describe his political opponents.

The question for me is: How do I do the same?

Am I doing it in my mind with Trump and his followers? Do I dehumanize them? Do I make them into caricatures in my mind?

Do I sometimes forget they are humans like me? With an equally rich inner life as me? With fears, hopes, dreams, hurts, wounds? Wanting to be free of suffering?

Do I sometimes forget they love and express kindness in other areas of life?

Yes, when I get caught up in my own scary stories about them, I temporarily do. I make them into caricatures. I dehumanize them.

And when I notice, I remind myself that these are real and full human beings with as rich inner life as me.

Their dehumanization and scapegoating is an expression of their pain and hurt. Hurt people hurt people.

That doesn’t make it any more acceptable, but it helps me understand them better and see them as humans first and foremost.

It also reminds me that they more essentially are consciousness, just like me. In their case, expressed through that particular body and psyche, with all its history, pain, and trauma.

We share collective trauma, just from living in this civilization. I can definitely relate to that.

We are all temporary and local expressions of this amazing living system we call planet Earth. We are the local eyes, ears, thoughts, and feelings of the universe.

When I dehumanize them, I dehumanize the parts of me they mirror. I marginalize these parts of me. I deepen their hurt. Instead, I can notice and embrace these parts of me. I have hurt in me. I sometimes respond to that hurt by scapegoating and dehumanizing. How is it to notice? To meet it with kindness? How is it to notice and allow? To ask these parts of me what they want, and give it to them? (Acceptance, noticing, kindness, love, support.)

Read More

Robert Reich: Is Donald Trump a fascist?

Robert Reich’s video on the difference between authoritarianism and fascism, and the question of whether Donald Trump is a fascist. (Spoiler: He ticks all the boxes.)

The last generation that experienced fascism in Europe before and during WW2 is now on the way out. They saw and experienced the horrors unleashed by fascism, while most people alive today have not experienced fascism. I can’t help to think that’s why some – even many – these days seem drawn to fascism, both in the US and Europe. They don’t know its horrors.

In addition, they don’t seem to be able – or willing – to learn from history. If they did, if they set out to learn about and from history, I can’t imagine they would want to try it again. It’s an experiment we know the conclusion to.

Not to speak of the utter idiocy of spending time creating yet another distraction from the single most important issue in our time, and perhaps in the history of humanity: our global ecological overshoot and ecological crisis.

Trump reflections IX – aka reflections on society and politics

Continued from previous posts…. These posts started out about Trump but have morphed into brief notes about society and politics in general.

Emotionally motivated reasoning. A good portion of our reasoning is emotionally motivated. I sometimes think that in a Life 101 track for young people, learning to recognize emotionally motivated reasoning (EMR) – and it’s strengths and pitfalls – would be included. It seems a basic and useful life skill.

Emotionally motivated reasoning is reasoning based on emotions. We use thoughts to match our emotions, or to justify and support our emotions. We feel empathy so have a view of egalitarian inclusiveness. We feel angry, so we come up with a reason we are angry and perhaps why someone else is to blame. We are afraid, and do the same. And this influences our political views and reasoning.

What are some of the signs of EMR? Reactivity. Defensiveness. Blame. Appearing unreasonable. Uninterested in alternate views. Discounting data that doesn’t fit.

We can learn to recognize this in ourselves and in others. When we recognize it in ourselves, it’s a reminder to stop. Notice our emotions. Be honest with ourselves what we feel. (Perhaps anger on the surface masking fear.) And reconsider our view. It can be difficult, but it has many rewards. It’s a practice in honesty. And it’s a practice in being more interested in reality than our cherished views and identities. We will always operate from EMR in some situations and areas of life, but we can learn to recognize and be more honest about it.

And when we recognize it in others, we will then be more able to use a similar process. Sometimes, it’s  appropriate to directly address reactivity and irrationality, but it can also make positions more entrenched. Another way is to approach it with genuine curiosity. What are the emotions behind it? What’s the fear? What do they really want and need? Perhaps there are other strategies for them to have their needs met? (This is similar to Nonviolent Communications.)

Read More

Trump reflections VIII

Continued from previous posts….

August 5, 2017

Trauma. What we see in Trump is typical trauma behavior. It’s not how everyone, or even most people, respond to or live out their trauma. But when we see that type of behavior (anger, reactivity, bigotry, impulsive behavior), it’s often rooted in trauma, in deep wounds.

Of course, it’s important to address the political issues, and it’s important to address the need for respect and a fact-based discourse in a democracy.

And it can also be helpful to remind ourselves that this is trauma behavior. It can be a spring board to look at how we respond to and live out our own trauma (whether it’s big or small), take it as an opportunity for trauma education, and also use it to look at how we can prevent and treat trauma in our society.

Trauma II. Similarly, I can’t help to wonder if not some Trump supporters are reacting to and living out their trauma in their support of him. Again, it’s important to address the political and social issues. But it can also be helpful to explore the possible trauma connections.

For instance, I wouldn’t be surprised if large portions of the US population are traumatized – directly and indirectly – by the significant social and economic inequality in the US. Which means they are traumatized by the policies coming out of neo-liberalism (which has become almost a religion in the US and most of the western world). And that’s why they support Trump because he, on the surface, seems to offer a way to deal with it. (Of course, he doesn’t.) His anger and bigotry plays to the trauma, and his words – at least during the campaign – spoke to the knowing of many of his supporters that neoliberalism is a cause of many of their problems.

In what way are people traumatized by social inequality? They are traumatized by lack of opportunities: lack of schooling, lack of good jobs, lack of money. And that, in turn, creates a life that creates more trauma (through drug use, illness, anger, depression etc.)

In what way is that connected to neo-liberalism? Neo-liberalism creates and deepens social and economic inequality. It’s built in. The wealthy get more wealth. The less wealthy tend to get even less wealthy, especially when the government doesn’t step in to moderate the worst effects of neo-liberalism.

In what way has neo-liberalism become a religion? It’s treated as sacred by many politicians and social commentators. It’s unquestioned. They tend to not address its inherent problems or any alternatives. (The best alternatives are known, but not by many and not implemented yet.)

In what way does Trump’s anger and bigotry play to the trauma? Some react to trauma with anger and bigotry. And to them, it feels like a relief to have someone like Trump in charge and visible in the media. He makes it OK to live out that particular reaction to trauma.

Read More

Trump Reflections VII

Continued from previous posts….

April 6, 2017

Public discourse. In general, I see good discussions and public discourse as a shared exploration. An exploration where we all learn, grow, and change our views to find what’s more aligned with reality, and what works better for all of us. But sometimes, people act against their own interest, or they are entrenched in a certain view, and it’s more a question of reaching them at all. That’s where it can be helpful to argue using their existing worldview and values.

Using their values. Arguing using facts and rationality sometimes works, especially if they fit the existing worldview and values of the recipient. But generall, it’s not what changes people’s minds. It can even make people’s opinions even more entrenched. That’s why it can be helpful to argue using the existing worldview and values of the recipient.

(a) What is their worldview and their values? Listen to them. Ask.

(b) How does this worldview, and how do these values, fit with X? Where X is a strategy that’s inclusive and supports life at all levels and in the short and long term, for instance universal health care, free quality education at all levels, sustainability etc.

(c) How do I tell an engaging and compelling story that shows how their values match these solutions and policies? How do I make it personal to them?

For instance, why are many conservatives in the US skeptical to climate change and creating a more sustainable society? It seems to make no rational sense. Somehow, their values have been hijacked to support policies that often are against their interests – and often their values. (Policies that are in the interest of only small segments of the population, and at the expense of society as a whole, ecosystems, and future generations.)

Say their values are….. creating a good world for their children and decendants, valuing God’s creation, maintaining healthy and supportive communities. I imagine these are values among many conservatives in the US. And it’s pretty easy to show that solutions such as universal health care, free quality education at all levels, and sustainability are aligned with those values, and good strategies to achieve goals aligned with their values.

Of course, it has to be genuine. We have to find these values in ourselves and find genuine connections between these values and the world we would like to see. And it will only resonate with some conservatives. But that’s a good start.

Post-modern nightmare. Trump’s way of dealing with “facts” is nightmare taken right out of post-modernism. In post-modernism, we realize that everything is a story, including data and facts. Taken to a naive extreme, they are all equal and equally valid. And from a more grounded and mature perspective, we know that some fit our experience better and that it’s important to have a consensus reality to work with. We can know it’s a fabrication, and we can still mostly agree on it and use it in everyday life. That’s how modern democratic societies mostly work.

Trump, Fox News, Breitbart and others take the post-modern insight to an extreme. They know very well what they are doing, and they do it to confuse, mislead, and – ultimately – for profit. Of course, authoritarian rules throughout history have done this. It doesn’t require postmodernism. Just a willingness to manipulate and mislead.

And it requires people willing to be manipulated and misled. Willing because it may give them temporary satisfaction.

May 18, 2017

Update. I don’t have much more to say here. What’s unfolding is all quite predictable, at least in the big lines. Trump is reckless with information and military actions. His unpredictability makes it hard for allies and security services to trust him, and it can easily trigger a serious military conflict somewhere in the world. He doesn’t know how the government works. He repeatedly creates reasons for impeachment, and it may go that way should the Republicans decide he is too much of a liability. His supporters still support him, largely because they receive their information from him or his media allies.

And it’s hard to say exactly where it will go from here. He may decide to resign, either from frustrations with the check and balances of democracy or because he is at risk of impeachment, and then blame his “enemies” for making his job impossible. He may create a war which may give him more support due to some misguided attitude Americans have to support their leader in times of war no matter what (or he may be impeached because he is too reckless). And it’s possible he will last four years and get re-elected. It’s hard to see that he can last that long with the amount of frustration he must be experiencing, but I guess he is used to – and may even enjoy – that level of drama and frustration.

My guess is that he will resign and blame his “enemies” so he can save face and still be a “winner” in his own view.

The new world. We are invited to create and support a new world, one that’s life centered and supports life at all levels – from ecosystems to individuals of all species. We have all the solutions to have a very good start if we decide to go in that direction and support and implement these solutions on a larger scale. We have the opportunity to create a new economy that’s as innovative and successful – and creates as many jobs – as any we have seen before. We have a very attractive possibility in front of us, and the alternatives are equally unattractive. (The main alternative is to continue on the same course and keep creating a great deal of ecological problems, which then – inevitably – become social and human problems.)

I guess what’s happening now is quite predictable as well. We have the old world order, especially clearly represented by Trump and the US Republicans, which desperately try to hold onto a world that has no future. We have some that try to maintain a middle ground, represented by the US Democrats and many traditional political parties in Europe, and are only moderately successful. And we have those who envision and partly live this new approach. These are still mainly overlooked by mainstream media so they are less visible.

How will this unfold? My guess is that since most countries and political leaders still hold on to many outdated approaches, we will have to live through more of the consequences of social inequality (unrest, wars, uprisings) and ecological destruction (lack of basic resources, diseases, unrest, wars). This may go on for a few decades.

And yet, we do have the solutions. We know what to do. One approach to this change is to make this information widely available, show that the alternatives can be very attractive, elect the right leaders, and restructure many aspects of our society so that what’s right (socially and ecologically) is also the easy and attractive options for governments, corporations, and individuals. More likely, some enlightened corporations (Tesla etc.) will lead the way and show that more life-centered solutions are more attractive all around, and people and elected officials will follow. In some regions of the world, we may also have political leaders who will restructure society in a more deep and thorough way.

Social inequality. To many of us, Trump and his supporters seem unhinged. Unhinged from reality. They appear reactive, unconcerned with reality, uncaring, irrational, acting from short-term perspectives, acting from narrow self-interest, and acting so they directly or indirectly harm themselves and others.

They don’t act like children. Children are usually far more mature and healthy, and far more caring. They act like emotionally damaged children. And, in a sense, they are since they live in a society of significant inequality that does not take care of everyone. This is how people who are harmed – through social inequality – act. Of course, that’s not new. We have seen this throughout history. It seems to be part of human life.

The best remedy may be to create a society that works for as many people as possible (the post-WW2 northern European societies may, so far, be the best examples of this). People living in a society where they feel included and cared for, where they receive good and free education, where the basics of life is taken care of, tend to know how rare and precious it is and want to maintain it, they tend to want to extend it to others, and they tend to – in general – appear a bit more mature (and less damaged).

Irrational. Human behavior is often irrational. We tend to focus on what’s immediate, dramatic, and emotional. The media knows that and plays into it by making news into entertainment and drama. That’s how they get viewers or readers.

And all of it is from evolution. For our ancestors, it was important to pay attention to anything that stood out and anything dramatic, and they rarely needed to pay attention to the big picture or slow trends. In a democracy, we need to get people to pay more attention to the serious and slower trends, and less on shorter term drama and entertainment. And we can do just that by taking evolution and how people really function into account, instead of wishful thinking about how people “should” function.

If we have sufficiently informed political and business leaders, we can set up structures so that what’s easy and attractive is also good in the long term and in the big picture.

And we can speak to people in general in ways that works with the mechanism put into us by evolution: Tell compelling stories. Make it simple, immediate, and personal. Show how it aligns with the values and identities they already have. Make it genuinely attractive.

May 25, 2017

Abusive father. From the little I know about Trump’s father, he seems to have been quite abusive to his children. I haven’t written about it here, and it doesn’t come up so often in the media, but Trump’s behavior is typical of a defiant teenager trying to stand up to his father. Why does he do it?, a Salon article by Lucian Truscott, describes the dynamics well.

It’s a reminder that how we all operate has infinite causes. Understanding gives empathy. And that understanding and empathy are independent of standing up to ignorance, abuse, and – in this case – dangerous policies. We can easily do both.

June 1, 2017

Climate change. Trump has, predictably, withdrawn the US from the international agreements on climate change. In some ways, it may not be so bad. The money and the future is in sustainable energy and technologies as is well known by many in the business and investing world.

The change to a more sustainable world is partly driven by economics (it’s profitable) and partly by policy. On the policy side, the US pulling out means that the rest of the world is free to proceed without US interference. (Which is also why the UN security council should be made away with.)

I am still puzzled by one thing: Climate change and sustainability is an amazing business and science opportunity. Why are Republicans against it? You would think they would support something that so clearly is good for innovation, new industries, and business, and would put the US (even more) in the forefront of the future more sustainable ways of doing everything. And yet, they don’t.

The one explanation is that this has to do with connection to the petroleum industry. The petroleum industry may be supporting Republicans financially to the extent that they are willing to override any wish to do what’s good for their children and the US business world and industry. They may assume that there is still enough time for others to pick up the pieces and do something more sane.

Maybe it’s not even that rational. Maybe it’s just an instinctive reaction towards anything that reminds them of liberals and do-gooders. Maybe it has more to do with identity. (And what they don’t want to be associated with.)

For Trump, pulling out of the Paris agreement may also be an expression of his “zero-sum-game” view on the world. If something is good for the world, it cannot be good for the US. Or if the world wants it, it cannot be good for the US. And this worldview is the mark of someone who is severely emotionally damaged.

Trump replacement. I see many wishing for Trump to resign or be impeached. It’s more or less likely to happen. But he will be replaced by another Republican (for instance Pence) who will implement many of the same policies and will do so in a far more sophisticated and “invisible” way. The one very good thing with Trump is that he is completely blatant and unsophisticated so he draws a a great deal of attention to what he is doing. (Although a lot of policy changes fly under the radar due to the media’s attention to his tweets and bizarre behavior.)

Why do Trump’s family support him? From the outside, it seems a bit puzzling.

I can imagine a few reasons. (a) They know how wounded he is, and that he is damaged from how his father treated him, so they have a natural understanding and sympathy for him. (b) They themselves are caught up in the unhealthy dynamics and don’t recognize them as unhealthy. (c) They recognize what’s going on but either feel trapped or play along for strategic reasons.

If there was only (a) it would make sense for them to stand up to him more. What we see are family members who seem a bit more sane than him, but also enabling and supporting him in his follies and insanities. That makes me think it’s either (b) or (c) or a mix of the two.

June 3, 2017

Media caught up in a system that rewards gore. On the one hand, it’s puzzling how the media chose to focus on immediate and dramatic issues rather than the far more serious and longer term ones. How can journalists live with themselves knowing their work serves as a distraction from what really needs our attention? (Of course, most of them just do what they are expected to do so they can put food on the table for their families.)

One the other hand, it’s very understandable. Most media organizations are for-profit organizations and sensationalism and gore sells. They are in the business of making money. And to do so most effectively, they intentionally tap into our tendency to be drawn to what’s unusual and dramatic.

That’s a tendency that has served our ancestors and species well. In small tribes, it pays to notice anything that’s unusual and dramatic. And most of the time, there is little need to pay attention to longer term trends. Life tends to go on as it did for our parents, their parents, and their parents before them.

The problem is that today more than ever, we need to focus on the big picture and the longer trends. So we are far better served by a media that gives us accurate information on just that, and is leaves the drama and sensationalism to the side. So the question is, how can we create a system where this is rewarded? Where this is the easy and attractive thing to do for the media?

One place to start is media literacy in schools, starting in elementary school. The more aware of how media works people are, the more incentive the media will have to function in a way that serves people’s real needs better. At the very least, we may see a greater demand for media that focuses on the real issues, the underlying causes of these, and real and practical solutions.

So what are the real issues? To me, they include increasing inequality within and between countries, and all the problems this creates. The large number of people dying of hunger and lack of clean water each day. (Far more than people dying from terrorism or violence in any form.) The large number of people crippled or dying from preventable diseases. Our need to organize ourselves collectively in a way that takes ecological realities into account.

A few words about reporting on terrorism. It does seem bizarre that the media choses to focus so much on small instances of terrorism. Typically, only a handful of people die which – of course – is tragic for those close to them. But for the vast majority of people, other issues are far more important. And these tend to be issues that the media either ignore or only pay attention to occasionally.

Also, by over-reporting on terrorism they are giving the terrorists exactly what they want. They give them attention. And through their blood-and-gore reporting they stoke fear in the population, and that too is exactly what they terrorists want. The media – and many politicians – play right into the hands of the terrorists. And that seems incredibly naive.

We can even say that it’s the way media reports on terrorism that makes it worthwhile for terrorists to commit acts of terrorism. No reporting, very little reason for terrorism. As it is today, media fuels terrorism.

Double vote for young people? Apart from instant run-off voting, mandatory voting, and other voting reforms, I wonder if not double votes for young(ish) people would make sense. In the Brexit vote last year, old people largely voted to leave the union while younger voted to stay, and – to put it bluntly – older people screwed over young people. It makes sense to give a double vote to the 50% younger people since these have a longer term perspective. Of course, the drawback is that younger people may not take the needs of the older into consideration.

Working for Trump. Trump has a history of screwing over those working with him. (Including suing and not paying contractors). I assume most people working with Trump will – at least at times – have to go against their own integrity and better judgment. And by being associated with him, they will – most likely – not be judged kindly by history. So it is somewhat surprising that some chose to work with him.

Of course, they may see it as a stepping stone to something else. They may hope they won’t get screwed or tainted too badly. They may think that it happens to others and they will be the exception. They may plan on writing an insiders view of how it was to work with him. They may hope to influence him one way or the other. Some may not care too much about integrity or how they may be seen by history. And some, I guess, may actually share some of his politics and be willing to put up with a great deal to help see it through.

NRK and hidden Islamophobia. NRK is the national broadcaster in Norway and normally relatively good. Although recently, they have had articles that (a) are unnesserary and (b) easily fuel anti-muslim sentiments.

A few days ago, a white guy in a van ran down people outside a mosque in London. And today, NRK has an article about the “murky past” of this mosque and why the killer had reasons for doing what he did. This is a type of reporting that can be justified by “only reporting the facts”, but the effect is to fuel up under anti-muslim sentiment.

Rationality vs intelligence. There is obviously a difference between rationality and intelligence. Only the most basic level of intelligence is required for rational thinking, and rational thinking can be learned and trained. Of course, rationality can be set aside if we are in the grips of strong emotions (for instance if our identity is threatened). And that happens in politics as well, especially when people vote against their own interests.

Identity and politcs. Identity plays a big role in politics. Some will vote for a particular party just because they always have, their parents have, and their friends do. Some are identified with a particular issue and vote for whatever party agree with them on that one issue, even if much else of their policies are against their interests. (I am thinking specifically about the weird politics around abortion in the US.) Identity sometimes trumps sanity and rationality.

Abortion. Having mention the politics around abortion, I’ll say a few more words about it. It has become a strangely polarized issue in the US, along with many other issues. To me, the most rational approach would be to (a) allow abortions since people will do it anyway and it’s safer to have it legal and regulated, and (b) implement policies and strategies shown by research to reduce the number of abortions (good sex education, easy access to free birth control etc.). I guess part of the reason I see this as the most sane approach is because I grew up in and still partially live in a country that takes this approach and it seems to work well.

Of course, sometimes a more rational approach is set aside in favor of ideology, and that happens on both sides of any issue.

June 9, 2017

Vaccines. This is a more general social and political issue. The debate about vaccines is strangely polarized, and there is little responsible, balanced, and sane public debate around it. Which is a shame since it’s an important topic. There is no doubt that vaccines – for instance for polio and small pox – has made a huge difference and saved a great number of lives.

There is also little doubt that the pharmaceutical industry has hijacked the policies to a large extent. It became especially obvious when the World Health Organization a few years ago called the current flu a “pandemic” and said everyone had to be vaccinated. That was so clearly something orchestrated by the pharmaceutical industry and not based on sound and rational medical advice.

To me, a more balanced view is to acknowledge that vaccines can and do save lives. The issue is not about vaccines in themselves but the toxins mixed in with the vaccines. Vaccines are sometimes recommended based on pressure from the pharmaceutical industry and not on a more balanced and down-to-earth medical advice. They do sometimes cause serious health problems in people. And one solutions is to find another way to do it that does not involve toxins.

July 29, 2017

Some people just want to watch the world burn. Sometimes, I imagine that Trump supporters, Brexiters, and others, just want to watch the world burn. They feel they have nothing to lose (even if they do), or – perhaps more to the point – they realize that others have more to lose, and they are willing to sit back and watch as society turns in a direction that doesn’t really benefit anyone. Equally likely, many live in a very different info-world from me, and they actually think that Trump and Brexit will do something good – as they see it. Or there is a mix.

The upside. Not much has changed in how I see Trump and the Trump situation. There are a few possible upsides:

(a) Many of his policies are similar to those of Republicans in general (with some honorable exceptions). And he reveals the Republican agenda in a crass and open way, without the typical sophistication. He brings it out in the open.

(b) He has triggered a public discourse and awareness (at least among some) about the value of fact checking, media literacy, a strong democracy, following the written and unwritten rules of a functioning democracy, and the general value – for a society and as individuals – of treating others with respect and acting with some dignity.

(c) He has revealed and brought awareness to how damaged many in the US seem to be. Damaged from lack of education and lack of opportunities in general. (It’s hard to imagine that many supporting him if this wasn’t the case.) Significant social inequality – and the anger and frustration it creates – is what brings people like Trump into political leadership positions.

Of course, he is also doing the opposite. His outrageous behavior distracts from many of the policies pushed through by Republicans in congress. He has made disrespectful and unhinged behavior acceptable – to some – by his example. And his policies will only deepen the social inequality within the US society.

August 4, 2017

Trump and the grand jury. They are setting up a grand jury to investigate the Russian connection, and Trump may well have to testify. It will be an interesting spectacle. It’s possible someone will write his testimony for him and he’ll be able to read it out loud without straying. But as a compulsive teller of non-truths and strayer from the script (as far as he ever has one), it’s likely he can’t help himself from lying under oath. And that’s one possible way his presidency ends.

How it will unfold. There are still many ways for his presidency to unfold, and right now none of them seem especially more likely than some of the others. He may be on course to be impeached, and will likely resign before that happens – blaming others and leaving the presidency to Pence. He may start a war so people will (misguidedly) rally around him and he’ll boost his popularity. He may muddle through his period, gain some political victories, and not run for re-election, lose, or possibly even be re-elected. Right now, anything seems possible.

Damaged and entitled. What explains Trump’s behavior? I can find a few things.

One is that he is damaged, most likely through a form of developmental (ongoing childhood) trauma, perhaps from how he was treated by his father. He is an example of how hurt people hurt people.

Another is entitlement and privilege. He has been sufficiently wealthy and privileged (and, I should add, unprincipled) to avoid the normal consequences and push-backs of behavior that gives most of us some self-awareness and helps us mature and grow as human beings.

A third is that he learned, through experience and perhaps examples, that his behavior works. It gets him what he (think he) wants. He gets to fire anyone troublesome to him. He gets adoration (however fake). He gets to feel important. He gets to boost his own ego (even if he knows the hollowness of it). He gets to be king in his own world.

This can sound like a put-down, but it’s also something that can help us see him more clearly and deal with him more effectively. It can even give us some empathy.

A dumb person’s idea of a smart person. As many have pointed out, Trump is a dump person’s idea of a smart person. A poor person’s idea of a rich person. A weak person’s idea of a strong person. It’s harsh but there is some truth to it.

Trump reflections VI

Continued from previous posts…

The right side of history. It can seem a bit arrogant to say that something is on the right or wrong side of history. After all, some will disagree, and who am I to make such a judgment?

At the same time, I feel it’s something we are allowed to say. What generally is supportive of life and people is on the right side of history. Policies that aim to support life and people, and especially the weakest ones and the ones with no voice, are on the right side of history. Why is that? It’s partly because the weakest and those with no voice includes future generations.

It’s also because these more inclusive policies tend to be the most beneficial to everyone in the big picture and over time.

Everything is politics. Everything is politics. We all have preferences, and those preferences are politics. They intersect with policies at a social level.

If we see something as not political, it’s often because the preferences built into it – whether it’s a religion, activity, or way of life – tend to be accepted or mirrored by the larger society. As soon as this is no longer the case, it becomes clear to us how political it really is.

Privilege. As many point out, saying that we are not interested in politics, or don’t want to get involved, comes from a position of privilege. It’s what we can say if life for us and those close to us is relatively good. It’s what we say if we ignore the situation of those less fortunate than us.

Why are spiritual people often more liberal? It’s completely possible to be into spirituality and still have a generally conservative view, especially if it’s a more kind and sane version of conservatism. And yet, spiritual people tend to be more liberal. I think there are several reasons.

One is that spirituality tends to come with a natural concern for the welfare of all beings. We realize, and it’s often an alive and lived realization, that we are all one. We are all expressions of Spirit. We are all connected as part of this living planet. And that concern is best reflected in more liberal policies.

Another is that religions have conservative elements built into them. Religions seek to preserve themselves and not change too much. And that fits a conservative mindset. Spirituality tends to be more open and experimental, and that fits a more liberal mindset. Of course, these are just general tendencies. Some branches of religion are quite liberal, and some traditions have spiritual elements that can be quite conservative.

Read More

Trump reflections V

Continued from previous posts.

Policies and democracy. Trump worries me and many others, and our main concerns are in two areas:

Policy content. He – supported by his cabinet and the Republican congress – are likely to implement policies that erode social safety nets, transfer what’s now publicly and collectively owned to private corporations, and tends to benefit people like them (billionaires) at the cost of regular people.

Democracy. Trump’s m.o. is to (a) deny the truth of something easily verifiable, and (b) turning it back on the other (blame, name calling). This erodes the democratic process, norms, and unwritten rules built up over decades and centuries. His authoritarian and bullying tactics belong to the world of old-fashioned kings and dictators, not a democracy.

What we can do. So what can we do? We need to be what we want to see in the world:

Emphasize facts and reality.

Act with integrity and uphold democratic norms and processes. Support order instead of his chaos.

Support forward-looking policies and what we want to see in our society. Remember and develop our visions of the society we want to have.

Remember that a majority of people in the US support liberal policies – when these are presented outside of party politics. Remember that Trump got only a quarter of the votes, and less than half of the votes cast.

Focus on the issues and not his personality. Hold the media to a high standard of accountable reporting. Act with sanity and maturity.

Collapse. Many have predicted the end of the US empire and Trump is actively engaged in making it happen. It doesn’t take much to predict it right now, it’s happening right in front of our eyes. And that’s not necessarily a bad thing.

What’s more concerning is the possible collapse of western civilization as we know it. The current version of our civilization is, as we all know, profoundly unsustainable. It can’t continue. The only question is how it will end and what will come instead.

If we take it seriously – far more than we have up to now – we can still create a relatively graceful transition to a more sustainable civilization. If we continue on our current path, and Trump even wants to reverse it, the transition may be in the form of a far more harsh collapse.

Trump as a useful idiot for Republicans. Many, including me, think that the Republicans will keep Trump for as long as he is useful to them. As soon as he becomes too troublesome – either in terms of damaging the Republican brand or by being too unpredictable and unruly – they’ll get rid of him. A Pence president won’t do the public any favors, but to the Republicans, he is far more predictable and in line with the Republican agenda. Robert Reich posted about this earlier today.

The upside. The possible upside of Trump and a Republican congress is that more people will wake up to what’s really going on. The Republican agenda is to line the pockets of the wealthy at the cost of ordinary people. And that’s what Trump is in the process of doing as well.

Even better would be if more people also wake up to the need and great benefit all around from creating a culture that’s aligned with ecological realities, but I doubt if the Trump situation can do that. Someone like Elon Musk are more likely to open people’s eyes.

A test. The Trump presidency is a test of sorts. It’s a test of our character. Again, it’s an invitation for us to be what we want to see in the world.

A mirror. At a more psychological level, Trump serves as a mirror. He serves as a mirror of what lurks in the US population. And he serves as a mirror for each of us. There is a simple way of exploring this.

Write a list of what you see in him. (He is… He should…)

Turn each statement around to yourself. (I am…. I should….)

Find three or more specific examples of how each statement is true for yourself – in this situation and other situations.

Read More

Trump reflections IV

Continued from previous posts.

Inclusiveness. I tend to judge policies and politicians less in terms of how liberal or conservative they are, and more on how inclusive and life-centered they are. There are policies and politicians of any flavor that take a more inclusive and life-centered approach. They sincerely wish society as a whole, and all segments within it, to flourish. And if they have a larger perspective, they also include nature and future generations. (Also because that’s enlightened self-interest. It’s to our benefit here and now to do so.)

That’s why it’s so hard for me to understand why people would support Trump. He is someone who so obviously is in it for himself and to increase profit for people like himself, at the expense of everyone else – including the less wealthy, nature, and future generations.

Of course, people may be mislead, and they may have wanted to vote for him out of reactiveness and pain. And still, from the beginning, it was so clear that he is in it for himself and that a vote for him was a vote for policies not in their own interest. At least not in the short term. Who knows what will come out of it in the longer term. His term may be such a blatant disaster that enough people come to their senses and support more sensible solutions.

Solution focus. I have always favored a partner-oriented and solution focused approach to our serious problems. It’s the only approach that makes sense to me. It’s what exciting and energizing, and what creates a life we want to live – for ourselves and society as a whole.

Of course, we need to focus on the problems in order to understand them and find a strategy to create what we want. But if we focus only or mainly on the problems, it tends to be very discouraging and lead to burn-out.

Read More

Trump reflections III

Continued from two previous posts.

Short memory. I can’t help thinking that what we see today – Trump becoming president and what he promotes gaining momentum in the western world – is allowed to happen only because people have short memories. They have already forgotten, or perhaps not really learned, about Hitler and WW2. They don’t know what mass scale intolerance, leaders acting on emotional reactivity, and rule by the financial elite, leads to. Only the oldest still have a personal memory, and in countries with poor education – such as the US – people haven’t learned the lessons thoroughly enough through school or the media.

That’s also why some of his supporters said “what do we have to lose?” when what they have to lose is a great deal. At least from the outside, it seems they don’t realize what they have to lose, or are educated well enough to know it viscerally. They don’t seem to have the larger historical picture.

This not the reason it happened, but it’s the reason it was allowed to happen: Those who still personally remember are too few to have a significant impact, and past lessons are too remote for a large enough segment of the population.

Diagnosing. I am not a fan of diagnosing anyone in public or at a distance. It’s unprofessional and can too easily be used to attack the person rather than addressing the issues. In Trump’s case, his very public behavior is enough to disqualify him from any position of leadership.

In a political context, there is no need to try to figure out the deeper why’s and how’s of his behavior. It’s only a distraction.

Trauma behavior. Still, in a psychological context, it can be interesting to explore what may be going on, knowing that it’s not really possible to diagnose at a distance. Being familiar with trauma behavior from working with clients and studies, I recognize what seems like trauma behavior. (Reacitvity, impulsivity, intolerance, dehumanizing others, recklessness, thin skinned, vengeance, short sightedness, not caring if what he says is true or not as long as he gets what he wants.) Trump seems to have made living from these trauma symptoms a badge of honor which only makes it more dangerous.

Repeating traumas. People who are traumatized tend to get themselves into situations where they repeat the trauma. They get themselves into those situations because it’s a familiar pattern. (It feels familiar and comfortable at some level, and they act from the trauma which creates similar situations as the initial traumatic situation.) And it’s also an invitation to recognize the trauma and seek healing for it. Some of Trump’s supporters may support him because his trauma behavior is familiar to them from their families and their own life.

More importantly, they may support him because they have had to suppress their own most destructive reactive trauma behavior due to social pressure and expectation, and here is someone who acts it out in public and, in essence, says “it’s OK to live and act from destructive reactive trauma behavior”. It can feel liberating for them to see it, and then use it to allow themselves to live more openly from their own trauma pain. Or, more precisely, act from their reactivity to their trauma pain which can take the form of anger, blame, bigotry, overly simplistic solutions, not caring about facts, and so on. It can feel good in the short run, but it’s definitely destructive in the longer run. In this case, it’s destructive on a large scale.

Said another way, it can feel good for them to say “fuck you” to the elite, but in this case, they only hurt themselves.

Action and compassion. This is pretty obvious. We can strongly oppose Trump’s policies, call him out when he is spreading untruths, and support what we want to see in the world. At the same time, it’s fully possible to have compassion for him and his pain. His pain is quite evident. He wouldn’t act the way he does if he wasn’t acting on his own pain. And we can have compassion and seek to understand his supporters. The two go hand in hand. They even support each other. (Strong action makes it easier to find compassion, and compassion leads to more clear and strong action.)

Disruption. In a bigger picture, who knows what will come out of this. In an evolutionary context, disruption often leads to new traits in existing species, new species gaining momentum, and a new course for evolution. The early oxygen crisis led to new opportunities for life. Dinosaurs dying out created space for mammals to flourish. Who knows what a Trump presidency will lead to in the bigger picture. It may or may not be what many of us wish for or would have chosen, but it may be something we can appreciate the gifts in.

Integral view. Life is a whole and we look at it from different angles. That means it’s good to look at anything from multiple angles to get a fuller picture, while also knowing that none, nor all of them together, is a final or absolute truth. If we want to be more systematic about it, we can use an integral model or map such as Ken Wilber’s. This is also true when we look at the Trump situation. Some of the “default” angles for me include: (a) The big picture. Lila. It’s the play of life or the divine.

Some of the “default” angles for me include:

(a) The big picture.

(i) Lila. It’s the play of life or the divine.

(ii) We don’t know what will come out of it. Historically and evolutionarily, disruptions often lead to something we find valuable and attractive, at least in the longer run. (iii) It’s an opportunity for each of us to live what we want to see in the world.

(iii) It’s an opportunity for each of us to live what we want to see in the world.

(b) Social/political. One of the reasons we have Brexit and Trump is neoliberal corporate globalization, international agreements aimed at maximizing profit for multinational corporations at the expense of people, nature, and future generations. People see this and know it’s wrong. And, unfortunately, the Democrats chose a candidate that embodies this misguided approach.

(c) Psychological. Trump and some of his supporters seem to act from reactivity to trauma pain. Their views and behavior are classic trauma symptoms. Hurt people can be reckless and hurt themselves and other people.

Read More

Trump is the healer

Trump is the healer.

As anyone pushing our buttons, he shows us what’s left. He shows us our wounds, traumas, and hangups.

And that can be very healing if we let it. In this case, it’s specifically an invitation to see where we stop ourselves from speaking up and acting to prevent harm from happening to others.

Some more things that come to mind:

I would never want him as a leader of anything, but now that he is…. how can I make the best out of it?

How am I like him? What do I see in him? (A bully, bigot, racist, xenophobe, habitual liar.) Where can I find that in my own life, with specific examples?

How do I let other bully me into being inauthentic? What are the fears? What do I find when I explore these? (Using The Work, Living Inquiries etc.)

When I use ho’oponopono, tonglen, loving kindness practice or similar on him, those supporting him, those harmed by his actions, and myself, what do I notice? Where is there resistance? What’s the fear? How is it to meet and inquire into that fear?

Trump may not last long, but while he is president, he can be a great healer…. if we allow him to be. He can mobilize many of us to action on behalf of dignity, life, earth, and future generations. He can be a mirror for ourselves, showing us what’s left.

Read More

Trump reflections II

Continued from a previous post.

Focus on the issues, not the person. A lesson from Italy and other places is to focus on the issues, not the person. Focusing on Trump’s insanity (a) distracts from the real issues, and (b) galvanizes the Trump supporters and makes their position even more entrenched. The issues are real and important enough. There is no reason to dilute it by focusing on Trump himself, no matter how tempting it may be.

Why is he so fascinating? That said, there is a huge temptation to focus on Trump’s personality. The media certainly gave him a huge amount of free airtime, and they did so because of his outrageous statements and behavior, and the drama and chaos he creates.

A deeper reason why people are drawn to focusing on his personality is that he reflects something in all of us. He is an outrageous caricature of some of the worst sides in all humans. He shows us our shadow. And that is inherently fascinating.

In that fascination is wisdom. There is an invitation for all of us to find ourselves in him. How would I describe him? (Write it down.) How does that apply to me? Find specific examples. (It may be that what I find in myself is much less strong, and appears in a different way. After all, he often functions as a caricature of these sides in us.)

Read More

Trump reflections

I think the biggest lesson of this election is this: People love a good story way more than they like reality. Trump lied constantly, and had neither the temperament, the experience, nor the plans to change American lives for the better… but he knows how to spin an enthralling yarn.

Everything he promised is objectively bullshit. People with actual experience in economics, immigration, constitutional law, etc. said as much. Experts in every area came out against him, but America didn’t care. They liked his stories where other people were to blame for their problems and everything had a simple, intuitive fix. The blatant lies didn’t matter, as long as the story made them feel good.

America didn’t just give the middle finger to the elites. They said “fuck you” to everyone with expertise, to everyone in positions of earned authority, everyone who was trying to tell them what to do. America said, “You’re not the boss of me, I’m going to vote for an authoritarian who will tell YOU what to do.”

– S.O’B

Written by a friend of mine on Facebook.

I have had many reactions to the Trump popularity and now election. Here are a few:

From this spring on, I – and others I know – had an intuitive knowing he would be elected. From this morning of, the morning of the election and even before any results came in – I had a sickening feeling in my body.

He is insane. He may be literally insane. His level of projection, bigotry, sexism, islamophobia, vengefulness etc. is off the charts.

He seems to take delight in creating chaos. That’s a very dangerous quality of a leader of any country.

He seems to take delight in denying reality. He repeats and indulges in dangerous lies even if they are easily shown to be lies.

Trump is not really fit to be the leader of anything, apart from perhaps some crazy reality TV show.

He speaks to very legitimate fears and concerns many people have, especially how politics often serve corporate interests over those of people (neoliberal globalization etc.) The bail-out of the banks, instead of jailing the ones responsible, is one of many examples of why people are rightfully distrustful of politicians. And yet, his solutions are uninformed, misguided, and ranging from terrible to disastrous.

Some people compare him to Hitler, and others say he is not nearly as bad. Hitler wasn’t nearly as bad either at the time he was elected. The parallels are, at the very least, scary.

I feel sad Bernie Sanders did not become the Democratic nominee. Polls at the time showed that he was much stronger against Trump (clear advantage) than Clinton (much closer). Bernie speaks to many of the same concerns as Trump but has sane, proven, and inclusive solutions.

I would have voted for Hillary Clinton if I could, but I am not at all enthusiastic about her. She is far too aligned with corporate interests. (I know that’s partly strategic on her part, but still…. it’s a poor strategy when corporate interests so often are not the interests of people, ecosystems, and future generations.)

What will happen now? I am not sure. Personally, I have had a sense for a few months that I would leave the US for a while. I would find it easier to deal with Trump watching him from another country.

Hopefully, the democratic party will reform and address the very real issues and concerns that got Trump elected. I also suspect that the Republican partly will be torn apart to some extent, with pro- and anti-Trump segments (that’s already happening).

Trump is notoriously unpredictable, so just about anything could happen. He’ll likely try to get as much through of his campaign promises as possible. There is no reason to think he will be much different from the person we saw during the campaign. The republican congress will support much of it, and may oppose or block some of his more extreme policies.

He will set a new low standard in public discourse and politics, and this will be a model for others to follow.

He will most likely undo a great deal of social and environmental progress made over the previous several decades. His presidency will set back any efforts to reduce the severity of climate change (already on track to be severe).

He is likely to cause rifts with other countries. In the worst case, we’ll see his vengefulness and unpredictability cause very dangerous international situations and conflicts.

Trump doesn’t have the experience – and perhaps not the inclination – to lead the country. So his advisors will probably do a lot of the work, as they did with G.W. Bush. And these advisors may be as or more dangerous – socially and environmentally – than Trump himself.

It’s possible that he’ll resign or lose his presidency within a year or two and we’ll get another Republican president. Someone a bit more level headed and predictable, but still one who can do a great deal of harm, especially in the social and environmental areas.

It’s also possible something good will come out of the destruction. He may motivate life-centered engagement more than anyone else. Out of the ashes, something new and more life-affirming may emerge. We’ll see.

Most likely, what happens will be a mix of several of these things. Typically, things won’t be as bad as we fear or as good as we hope, although Trump has a way of go outside of the norm.

My hunch: He will go after his enemies (and will be partially stopped by courts and the law). He will try to get as many things done in as short a period as possible. He’ll get nearly full support of some Republicans, although many will oppose some of his more extreme projects. He will resign within one or two years, giving a reason that allows him to save face. (That he wants to focus on his family and/or TV network or another business project.) Another Republican will take over and continue some of his more regressive social and environmental policies but in a more professional manner. (Which, in some ways, is more dangerous.) A Democrat will be elected in 2020. This person will be slightly more in the Bernie Sanders camp. It could be Elizabeth Warren, but I think it will be someone else who is slightly more mainstream in their views. (Elon Musk would have been an exciting possibility, but he is not born a US citizen.)

Here is a post from early on the election day from another friend of mine:

If Trump wins, it is my belief that he will bring forth the movement, the revolution, faster than Clinton would because people will be much more motivated to do so. So fret not, if he wins, if the dark worker wins, (and dark workers are just as important in history as light workers) there will be revolutionary change even faster, but with more unfortunate consequences, drama, and maybe even fatalities. With Clinton in place, the movement will be slower going, safer and boring in comparison, but either way the Bernie movement will happen! I KNOW it in my bones that in my lifetime I will see the World fall apart and put itself back together again.”

My prayer now: Let the falling apart be as swift and light and easy as possible for all involved. Let curiosity diffuse fear and show everyone the magic that’s possible when anger expressed is met with an innocent heart. Anger is more fear after all, it’s just bigger looking and sounding. It’s scarier and hence creates more fear.

In the coming days and weeks and months I will strive to continue to grow my capacity to deal with fear and anger in myself and anyone who expresses it around me. When I feel it or see it, I will use it as my cue to get curious as much as possible. To find beauty in the moment as much as possible with everyone I meet.

Finding the blessings and beauty in any tense situation diffuses it immediately. Try it yourself. Next time you see someone angry or afraid, find anything to compliment them about genuinely. See what happens. Let me know if you do it. I’m so curious!

– MB

Update the following morning: for the last several months, my thoughts have sometimes said “he can’t possibly be voted in” but my knowing has said otherwise. Now, my thoughts try out “it won’t be that bad” but again there is a sense in me saying otherwise. It may be as bad as we fear, or worse.

With regular democrats and republicans, there is a regular level of craziness. They may go to war for oil or to get a regional foothold, or even to line the pockets of contractors. They may change some social and environmental policies. But in general, they keep things pretty stable. With Trump, it’s easy to imagine that it can spiral out of control. He is Loki, a chaos maker, and someone who seems to delight in chaos. It may lead to a situation beyond what most people are currently willing to imagine, as this historical analysis points out.

Read More